NU Scholars Issue Fatwa: Spreading Past Misdeeds Online Permissible for Public Interest
The Bahtsul Masail session of the Waqi’iyah Commission, held during the 2026 National Consultative Assembly of NU Clerics and Grand Conference, has decreed that re-sharing the past flaws or misdeeds of an individual on the internet is fundamentally forbidden as it constitutes ‘ghibah’ (backbiting).
However, an exception is granted if the information is required for the public interest, particularly to assess the integrity and capability of candidates for official or government leadership positions. This decision was part of the Bahtsul Masail results from the Waqi’iyah Commission held in Kediri on 20-21 June 2026. A primary discussion point included the legality of deleting digital footprints, also known as the ‘Right to be Forgotten’ (RtBF), in the internet era.
In addressing this issue, the Waqi’iyah Commission highlighted how advancements in information technology allow personal data, legal histories, and past mistakes to be permanently accessible via search engines and various digital platforms. Such conditions are deemed to have the potential to cause social and psychological harm to individuals seeking to reform their lives.
Nevertheless, the Chairman of the PBNU Bahtsul Masail Institute (LBM), KH Mahbub Ma’afi, revealed that NU clerics emphasised that re-spreading someone’s flaws can be justified if done for purposes recognised by Sharia. One such purpose is providing the public with information regarding the track records of prospective officials or leaders.
“Fundamentally, spreading flaws is forbidden, but NU clerics agree that re-sharing them can be justified if done for interests recognised by Sharia, including informing the public about the track records of leadership candidates,” stated Kiai Mahdub when confirmed by Republika on Thursday (25/6/2026).
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/nu-scholars-issue-fatwa-spreading-past-misdeeds-online-permissible-for-public-interest-1782352291)
Originally published by Republika (https://khazanah.republika.co.id/berita/th5y59483/ulama-nu-berfatwa-penyebaran-aib-di-internet-ada-yang-dibolehkan-menurut-syariat-ini-alasannya), translated from Indonesian