Notary Challenges PNBP Law in Constitutional Court Over Rp15 Million Fee Before Retirement
A notary, Anisitus Amanat, has filed a lawsuit regarding Law Number 9 of 2018 concerning Non-Tax State Revenue (PNBP) at the Constitutional Court (MK).
In case Number 203/PUU-XXIV/2026, the lawsuit was filed due to alleged constitutional losses resulting from the obligation to pay PNBP fees of Rp7.5 million for each term extension two years prior to retirement—specifically from ages 67 to 68 and 68 to 69—totaling Rp15 million.
According to the Constitutional Court’s press release, the petitioner argues that the tariff amount is disproportionate to the one-year term extensions and creates unfair and discriminatory treatment. During the Preliminary Examination Hearing, Anisitus also stated that the norms in Article 4, paragraph (3) of Law Number 9/2018 contradict the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia, as compulsory levies for state purposes and matters concerning state finances should be regulated by law, rather than through Government Regulations (PP) or Ministerial Regulations.
Consequently, he argues the provision should be declared conditionally unconstitutional unless interpreted such that the types of PNBP mentioned in paragraph (2) are regulated by law. Anisitus further alleged violations of the right to fair legal certainty and equal treatment before the law under Article 28D, paragraph (1), as well as the right to be free from discrimination under Article 28I, paragraph (2) of the Constitution. He supported this by comparing the PNBP rates imposed on notaries with those for other services, such as fiduciary security registration, which he claims are lower despite involving much larger transaction values.
The petitioner also noted that following Constitutional Court Decision Number 84/PUU-XXII/2024, notary terms can be extended annually until age 70; however, these extensions are burdened by PNBP payments at every stage. Therefore, in his petition, he requests the Court to declare the phrases granting authority to regulate PNBP types and tariffs via Government Regulations and/or Ministerial Regulations in Article 4, paragraph (3) and Article 8, paragraph (3) of the PNBP Law as unconstitutional and without binding legal force. He also requests the Court to affirm that the types and rates of PNBP for the notary profession must be regulated by law.
Constitutional Judge M. Guntur Hamzah advised the petitioner to be cautious, noting that the petitioner is seeking a specific interpretation while the norm already mentions regulation by law. He suggested that instead of seeking a new interpretation, the petitioner could simply request the deletion of the references to Government Regulations and Ministerial Regulations to achieve the desired legal outcome. Guntur noted that the petitioner had not yet clearly distinguished whether the issue was one of constitutional normality or mere implementation.
Constitutional Judge Daniel Yusmic P. Foekh advised the petitioner to include evidence of the notary term extensions to prove his standing. He also reminded the petitioner that the Constitutional Court does not have the authority to adjudicate technical regulations and urged him to focus on the testing of the law itself. Furthermore, he cautioned the petitioner to consider the potential legal vacuum that might occur if references to Government Regulations and Ministerial Regulations were removed.
Finally, Chief Justice Suhartoyo questioned whether the dispute over the specific PNBP tariff amounts falls within the Court’s jurisdiction, as the grievance appears to relate to the empirical implementation and the financial burden of the figures rather than the legality of the levy itself. Before closing the session, Suhartoyo informed the petitioner that amendments to the petition must be submitted to the Court no later than Wednesday, 1 July 2026, at 12:00 WIB.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/notary-challenges-pnbp-law-in-constitutional-court-over-rp15-million-fee-before-retirement-1781855571)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20260619124521-4-744045/wajib-bayar-rp-15-juta-jelang-pensiun-notaris-gugat-uu-pnbp-ke-mk), translated from Indonesian