Not Layoffs: Labour Union Leader Reveals Method Used to 'Kick Out' Employees
At least within the last decade, a phenomenon has been developing within companies. This involves employee efficiency not through formal layoffs (PHK), but by offering early retirement programmes to workers. This practice has reportedly been ongoing for years and has become one of the methods used by companies to reduce the number of permanent employees.
This was revealed by the President of the All Indonesia Workers Union Association (ASPIRASI), Mirah Sumirat. She assessed that this phenomenon is related to changes in the pattern of employment relationships within companies. Long-serving permanent employees are gradually decreasing, while their positions are subsequently filled by workers with contract or outsourcing status.
“The phenomenon of offering early retirement began about 5 years ago. In fact, looking back, it has been occurring for about 10 to 5 years. So, they are indeed removing long-standing permanent employees and replacing them with employees placed under outsourcing and contract status,” Mirah told CNBC Indonesia on Monday (28/9/26).
This pattern means that early retirement programmes do not exist in isolation. As long as there are long-term permanent workers, offers to terminate service early can emerge as part of the process of reducing permanent staff.
On the other hand, there is another pattern that can lead workers to choose to leave a company. Changes in work locations are one of the issues highlighted, as they can place workers in a difficult position when deciding whether to accept a transfer or leave their jobs.
“For example, in banking, as happened to my members in one of the banks. First, early retirement is offered. Second, they are then transferred to regional areas, which ultimately leads employees to refuse. When they refuse, they eventually resign,” said Mirante.
This choice can create different problems for workers. When a resignation occurs after a worker refuses a transfer, the worker’s position is no longer the same as when the company offered an early retirement programme.
In such situations, workers face equally difficult choices. Staying means accepting changes in working conditions that may not align with their wishes, while refusing can lead to the decision to terminate the employment relationship by their own choice.
“If they refuse, it means they resign, and the company does not provide severance pay. The early retirement programme effectively disappears when employees are transferred or relocated to areas where they feel uncomfortable, dislike, or are unwilling to go,” said Mirah.
This phenomenon is also believed to be occurring in more than just one company. Similar patterns are reportedly found in several other companies, meaning workers are facing increasingly diverse patterns of workforce management.
“This is not just happening in one company. Several other companies are doing the same. Therefore, there is a uniformity in programmes, one of which is early retirement and transfers to regions that can be predicted will cause workers to refuse,” said Mirah.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/not-layoffs-labour-union-leader-reveals-method-used-to-kick-out-employees-1790585658)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20260928132417-4-771453/bukan-phk-bos-buruh-bongkar-fenomena-tendang-karyawan-pakai-ini), translated from Indonesian