Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Non-Government Tax Collectors: A State Duty Imposed on the People

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Economy
Non-Government Tax Collectors: A State Duty Imposed on the People
Image: CNBC Indonesia

From 1 August 2026, millions of merchants across various marketplaces will find part of their sales proceeds deducted before being received—by the platform on which they transact, not by the tax office—under the new Income Tax (PPh) Article 22 scheme for Trade Through Electronic Systems (PMSE).

This phenomenon is not new. The term withholding tax has long existed for PPh and Value Added Tax (VAT) through Withholding Agents (WAPU), alongside the mechanism of offsetting Output Tax against Input Tax by Taxable Entrepreneurs (PKP).

Although both involve third parties in tax collection, the character of WAPU for PPh differs from WAPU for VAT. In PPh, the withholding generally settles the tax obligation on that transaction.

In VAT, WAPU is only part of a longer chain of administration, because the final obligation is still determined through the Output VAT and Input VAT mechanism. Moreover, VAT follows the accrual principle, so tax can be due from the moment goods or services are delivered, even if payment has not yet been received.

As a result, delays or errors by WAPU in collecting or remitting tax can create a far greater administrative burden and cash-flow risk for businesses. This piece intends to discuss the position of WAPU in VAT, which is vulnerable to legal discrimination and injustice.

Two Broad Groups of WAPU

The development of VAT WAPU shows that not all collectors stand in the same position. Government WAPUs are government treasurers, state-owned enterprises (SOEs) directly owned by the state, and oil and gas contractors substantively carrying out state interests.

Non-Government WAPUs are private business entities appointed to perform this function without being part of the state apparatus, such as specially designated SOE subsidiaries and PMSE operators.

This distinction reflects a fundamental shift in tax administration: originally, the collection function was carried out by state officials or parties directly representing state interests; now, that function is being loaded onto private businesses that remain subject to corporate law and commercially oriented.

Discussions of tax justice have focused on who pays tax and how much. Yet there is another dimension: who bears the administrative burden, compliance costs, and legal risk in performing the collection function itself.

Two Roles and the Irony Behind Sovereignty

The difference between Government and Non-Government WAPU is not merely about who collects the tax, but about who exercises state authority. Article 23A of the 1945 Constitution grants the state the authority to collect tax as a public power (imperium).

The constitutional obligation of citizens, by contrast, is only to pay in accordance with legislation; the Constitution never obliges citizens to help carry out the collection function over third-party transactions.

When a private business is appointed as WAPU, it remains a private legal entity subject to corporate law and commercially oriented, yet the state loads onto it part of an administrative function that is inherently a public authority. The dual role it performs will inevitably carry costs and risks.

In a democracy, the state is not the owner of sovereignty. Article 1 paragraph (2) of the 1945 Constitution affirms that sovereignty lies in the hands of the people; the government merely executes that mandate, including managing tax administration financed by the public’s taxes.

This debate emerged as early as the drafting of the 1945 Constitution. During the BPUPKI sessions, Maria Ulfah Santoso questioned whether guarantees of citizens’ rights needed to be explicitly enshrined in the constitution. Some members considered this unnecessary because sovereignty rested with the people.

But Muhammad Hatta took a different view: precisely because the state is merely the executor of the people’s mandate, the constitution must limit its power and explicitly guarantee the people’s rights, lest it drift into a state of unchecked authority.

From this perspective, loading the WAPU function onto private businesses becomes an irony. The state establishes institutions, pays its officials, and finances administration with taxpayers’ money, yet part of the work is still outsourced to private businesses without commensurate protection. The people who finance that administration end up performing it themselves.

When the Law Applies Differently

The difference between Government and Non-Government WAPU also emerges when collection fails. The statute makes no normative distinction between the two: treasurers and Non-Government WAPU alike can be held accountable if collected tax is not remitted. Yet this normative equality does not mean practical equality.

A treasurer is part of the state financial management system. Before becoming a criminal matter, a Treasury Claim/Compensation (TP/TGR) mechanism under the Financial Supervisory Board is available, allowing administrative resolution first. Non-Government WAPU has no comparable mechanism; there are only provisions that impose sanctions directly, whether administrative or criminal.

A similar pattern applies to protection for those performing their duties: Article 36A of the KUP Law protects tax officials acting in good faith, both civilly and criminally. Does this apply to Non-Government WAPU when sued civilly or prosecuted criminally?

Equal Obligations, Unequal Compensation

This asymmetry is not only about legal protection but also economics. Tax officials receive salaries and performance allowances to carry out this function, and the state continues to allocate large budgets for modernising and digitising tax administration.

Non-Government WAPU performs the same function without special compensation, providing its own systems, human resources, and infrastructure, while bearing compliance costs and legal risks. The broader the scope of Non-Government WAPU, the greater the administrative costs transferred from the state to businesses.

Practice in many US states differs: businesses collecting sales tax on behalf of the state receive a vendor discount as compensation for part of the administrative cost. The amount is small, but the principle is recognised: a public function imposes costs that deserve compensation.

Restructuring the Delegation of State Functions

The issue is not the existence of WAPU as an administrative instrument; appointing third parties to assist tax collection is widely recognised and has proven to improve revenue effectiveness. The problem is the balance when a public function is performed by private businesses: the greater the function imposed, the greater the state’s responsibility to ensure balance in obligations, legal protection, and compensation.

At least three things deserve consideration: proportional compensation for the administrative costs of Non-Government WAPU; legal protection for WAPUs acting in good faith, so administrative errors do not automatically become criminal matters; and, specifically for VAT WAPU, room for taxpayers transacting with it to use a cash basis without sanctions, so the tax burden aligns with their economic capacity.

Ultimately, this piece does not question the obligation to pay tax or the effectiveness of the WAPU mechanism. What it questions is the limit at which the state asks businesses to perform part of its function.

A state under the rule of law that places sovereignty in the hands of the people: the delegation of public authority should not merely transfer obligations to private businesses, but must also be accompanied by a balance of rights, protection, and responsibility.

Indonesia, a state under the rule of law, supreme sovereignty in the hands of the people, tax in accordance with the statute—right?

Note: This article is the author’s personal opinion and does not reflect the views of the CNBC Indonesia editorial team.

More from 11 July 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/non-government-tax-collectors-a-state-duty-imposed-on-the-people-1783723838)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20260711052339-14-750014/wajib-pungut-non-pemerintah-tugas-negara-yang-dibebankan-ke-rakyat), translated from Indonesian
Print