No Standard for Internship Allowances, 6 Students Challenge Manpower Law
Six students have filed a judicial review against Law Number 1ability 13 of 2003 concerning Labour (the Labour Law) at the Constitutional Court (MK), following the absence of a minimum standard for internship allowances.
This judicial review is registered under case number 214/PUU-XXIV/2026. The Constitutional Court judges held a Preliminary Examination Hearing, presided over by the Chief Justice of the Constitutional Court, Suhartoyo, on Wednesday (24/6/2026).
During the initial hearing, the petitioners stated that Article 22 of the Labour Law contradicts Article 27 paragraph (2), Article 28D paragraph (1), and Article 28D paragraph (2) of the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia. The petitioners include students Aisya Nayla Bihesthi Zewar, Leres Shafa Azzahra Anshori, Lourensya Varaniko, Aulia Mirza Nabilla, Brillian Fairuz, and Pascal Ibnu Kusuma.
“We wish to present the essence of our petition, which is to declare Article 22 of Law Number 13 of 2003 concerning Labour in conflict with the 1945 Constitution, specifically regarding Article 27 (2), 28D (1), and 28D (2),” stated the second petitioner during the preliminary examination, as reported on Thursday (25/6/2026).
Article 22 of the Labour Law under review stipulates: (1) Internships are carried out based on an internship agreement between the participant and the employer, made in writing. (2) The internship agreement must at least include provisions regarding the rights and obligations of the participant and the employer, as well as the duration of the internship. (3) Internships conducted without such an agreement are considered invalid, and the participant’s status shall change to that of a worker/labourer of the respective company.
In their petition regarding Article 22, the petitioners argued that their constitutional rights under Article 2/27 of the 1945 Constitution are harmed by the enforcement of this article. As students, the petitioners claim they are denied the opportunity for decent work and a proper livelihood.
The petitioners noted in their application that active students participating in internships do not receive adequate rights due to the lack of a minimum allowance standard, which directly legitimises the practice of providing inhumane compensation. Ultimately, this leads to the loss of their right to a decent livelihood.
“The absence of a minimum wage or allowance standard in the Labour Law leaves petitioners without legal protection against potential exploitation by internship providers who offer compensation far below the minimum cost of living,” the petitioners stated in their legal documents.
They further argued that companies tend to utilise interns to handle full operational workloads but with zero or significantly inadequate compensation. This creates a phenomenon of ‘shadow workers’ who bear responsibilities similar to formal employees but without the economic rights guaranteed by the state.
Consequently, they believe the lack of a minimum allowance limit in the law renders the ‘agreement’ in internship contracts a mere formality (a contract of adhesion). Sociologically, they argue that interns are forced to accept substandard working conditions because they have no other choice to advance their careers or education, meaning the state is effectively permitting the exploitation of its vulnerable citizens.
Furthermore, students who have completed at least four semesters are required by curriculum to undertake internships in companies, law firms, or government agencies as a graduation requirement. This is based on the Rector’s Regulation of the State University of Surabaya Number 18 of 2023 regarding the Implementation of Merdeka Belajar-Kampus Merdeka, in conjunction with the Ministry of Education, Culture, Research, and Technology regulations.
“The lack of a minimum wage standard forces interns, especially in large cities with high living costs, to personally bear internship operational costs (transportation, food, and accommodation). This creates a paradox where the people (via family/parental subsidies) are essentially financing the operations of business entities,” they stated in the petition.
According to the petitioners, Article 13 paragraph (2) of the Minister of Manpower Regulation Number 6 of 2020 regarding the Implementation of Domestic Internships actually stipulates that: “The allowance referred to in paragraph (1) letter d includes transportation costs, meal allowances, and incentives for internship participants.”
Based on these arguments, the petitioners request the Court to declare Article 22 of Law Number 13 of 2003 concerning Labour unconstitutional—specifically regarding Article 27 (2) and 28D (1) and (2)—conditionally, and to render it without binding legal force.
Specifically, they seek a ruling that the law must be interpreted to mean: “Every internship implementation, including those involving students, must guarantee legal certainty regarding the rights of participants, including the provision of adequate compensation that at the very least considers a fair and proportional minimum allowance standard in accordance with the workload, working hours, and contribution provided by the intern.”
During the Preliminary Examination Hearing, Constitutional Judge M. Guntur Hamzah advised the petitioners to ensure their legal standing is clearly linked to the norms being challenged, noting that if they have previously completed internships, they should provide details.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/no-standard-for-internship-allowances-6-students-challenge-manpower-law-1782366766)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20260625103026-4-745598/tak-ada-standar-uang-saku-magang-6-mahasiswa-gugat-uu-ketenagakerjaan), translated from Indonesian