No-Promotion Policy for Primary to Senior High School Students to Return; House Commission X Raises Concerns
Commission X of Indonesia’s House of Representatives has raised several points concerning plans to reinstate the policy under which pupils from primary to senior high school may be required to repeat a year. The policy is due to take effect in the 2027/2028 academic year.
Deputy Chair of Commission X MY Esti Wijayanti said all factions on the commission supported the proposed policy. She said it had been discussed, although further meetings would be needed to finalise the details.
“We support it, but there will certainly be further discussions, as there are many things we also need to consider,” Esti said at the PDI-P Party School on Wednesday (21 October).
Esti, who heads the PDI-P Central Executive Board’s youth and sport division, said the policy had in fact been in place for a long time and was only withdrawn during Nadiem Makarim’s tenure as minister.
She said that although the policy’s removal had made things easier for pupils, many had consequently lost motivation to study. As a result, many lacked basic literacy skills, including reading.
“In some places, children are even graduating from primary school without being able to read fluently,” Esti said.
Esti therefore believes reinstating the policy could help motivate pupils again. However, she warned that the psychological impact on students must be considered once the policy is officially implemented.
Overall, she believes the policy would be much more effective, since the curriculum sets standards that pupils are expected to achieve during each year of study.
“If they have not mastered the minimum requirements for understanding a subject, then they should have to repeat it,” she said.
Esti said the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education could refer to the previous guidelines when implementing the policy. Teachers and schools, she said, should provide additional support to pupils who are struggling with particular subjects.
This support could begin in the first term of the school year and should involve parents as well as teachers. Esti said textbooks provided to pupils should also be carefully reviewed.
“That means these books should be suitable, and their educational approach should be consistent with pedagogical theory,” she said.
Primary and Secondary Education Minister Abdul Mu’ti said the policy had received President Prabowo’s approval. The government is also preparing a policy on subject specialisation for pupils, which has likewise been approved by the President.
Both policies still require their regulations and technical rules to be finalised before they can be implemented in the 2027/2028 academic year.
On the previously discussed proposal for free schooling, Abdul Mu’ti said the government was seeking to strengthen public confidence in the provision of education.
“However, the explanation in the available statement is incomplete, so it cannot yet be described in further detail,” he said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/no-promotion-policy-for-primary-to-senior-high-school-students-to-return-house-commission-x-raises-concerns-1792572737)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261021142148-32-1417977/aturan-tak-naik-kelas-sd-sma-berlaku-lagi-komisi-x-dpr-beri-catatan), translated from Indonesian