Nine Constitutional Court Judges Who Heard Gibran Diploma Challenge Did Not Breach Ethics, Says Ethics Council
Jakarta — The Constitutional Court’s Honour Council (MKMK) has ruled that the nine Constitutional Court (MK) judges who handled a case concerning Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s diploma did not breach ethical rules.
The council rejected the complaint in full at a hearing into alleged ethical violations by the nine judges. “It is decided that the complainant’s report is rejected in its entirety,” MKMK presiding judge I Dewa Gede Palguna said at the hearing on Thursday (5 November 2026).
The complaint was filed by Pian Andreo Halomoan Manurung, chairman of the Indonesian Student Forum (Formasi), and registered as Case No. 05/MKMK/L/10/2026.
The complainant argued that the judges had breached the principle of independence by using the court’s authority to show Gibran’s diploma to Denny Indrayana, one of the petitioners. The complainant also said that the judges’ decision to schedule hearings directly to examine evidence from the petitioner and respondent, the General Elections Commission (KPU), as well as statements from related parties and the Election Supervisory Agency (Bawaslu), was driven by pressure from the public, the media and political forces.
In its reasoning, the MKMK referred to a global phenomenon in which judicial institutions become involved in political disputes. This can happen so that political issues are not left unresolved indefinitely, it said.
The council said such involvement was normal, including in the Constitutional Court’s consideration of the educational qualification requirement concerning Gibran in Case No. 1/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026. The real problem, it said, would be if judicial institutions were influenced by, or themselves influenced, political manoeuvring.
The MKMK ruled that the judges’ handling of the challenge to Gibran’s educational qualifications did not violate the principles of competence or diligence.
“Accordingly, the respondent judges’ decision to examine the substance of the case, rather than stop at examining the formal requirements of the petition in Case No. 01/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026, was a choice based on their approach to the law and reached collectively. It therefore did not breach the principles in Sapta Karsa Hutama, particularly competence, diligence, wisdom and prudence,” the MKMK judge said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/nine-constitutional-court-judges-who-heard-gibran-diploma-challenge-did-not-breach-ethics-says-ethics-council-1793872302)
Originally published by VIVA.co.id (https://www.viva.co.id/berita/nasional/1941286-9-hakim-mk-pengadil-gugatan-ijazah-gibran-tak-langgar-etik-mkmk-singgung-fenomena-peradilan-dunia), translated from Indonesian