Nine Constitutional Court Judges Reported to Ethics Council Over Gibran Diploma Dispute
Nine judges of the Constitutional Court (MK) have been reported to the Constitutional Court Ethics Council (MKMK) regarding alleged ethical violations in handling the dispute over the diploma of Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka, registered under number 01/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026. The nine judges were reported by the Chairman of the Indonesian Student Forum (Formasi), Pian Andreo Halomoan Manurung.
Pian believes the Constitutional Court judges violated the principle of independence by using their authority to present Gibran’s diploma to Denny Indrayana, who is one of the petitioners.
“From the beginning, one of the petitioners, Denny Indrayana (Petitioner III), issued a contest regarding the presentation of Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s diploma with the promise and/or reward of a certain amount of money. Therefore, it is suspected that the alleged violators, in examining and adjudicating this case, received incentives and/or rewards from Denny Indrayana by using the authority of the Constitutional Court to present the Vice President’s diploma to him,” stated Saddan Sitorus, the legal counsel for the complainant, during the preliminary examination hearing for Report Number 05/MKMK/L/10/2026, as seen on the Constitutional Court website, mkri.id, on Wednesday (7/10/2026).
According to Saddan, Constitutional Court judges should remain independent from pressure from the public, mass media, and the parties involved in a dispute. Since 2023, many parties have questioned the diploma of the 7th President of the Republic of Indonesia, Joko Widodo, and subsequently questioned the diploma of his son, Gibrante Rakabuming Raka, which has become a focus of public, media, and political attention—an agenda the complainant suspects is politically motivated.
Saddan assesses that the actions of the constitutional judges, who immediately scheduled a trial with an agenda for evidence from the Petitioners and the Respondent (KPU), relevant parties, and Bawaslu, are heavily influenced by public, media, and political pressure. According to Saddan, the judges should have studied and assessed the petition and conducted an evidentiary examination, rather than proceeding directly to the evidentiary agenda.
Consequently, Saddan believes that due to these pressures, the judges have violated the principle of independence. “Based on the points above, the Complainant considers that the alleged violators have breached the principle of independence because of suspected public, media, and political pressure, as well as the alleged promise of money made by one of the petitioners, Denny Indrayana,” he said.
Saddan has requested the MKMK to form an Independent Expert Team to assist in examining the complaint. The MKMK is also asked to objectively and neutrally investigate the alleged ethical violations by the judges in accordance with Constitutional Court Regulation Number 09/PMK/2006 regarding the Declaration of the Code of Ethics and Conduct for Constitutional Court Judges, known as Sapta Karsa Hutama.
Furthermore, the MKMK has been asked to temporarily suspend and/or halt proceedings for case number 01/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026 until the investigation into the alleged ethical violations is complete. The MKMK is also urged to impose heavy sanctions, including permanent dismissal, if the judges are proven to have committed ethical breaches.
Saddan also requested that all decisions and/or determinations made by the judges in examining and adjudicating case number 01/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026 be annulled.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/nine-constitutional-court-judges-reported-to-ethics-council-over-gibran-diploma-dispute-1791371039)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8696802/9-hakim-mk-yang-tangani-gugatan-ijazah-gibran-diadukan-ke-mkmk), translated from Indonesian