Nine Constitutional Court Judges Reported to Ethics Council Over Gibran Case
Jakarta (ANTARA) - Pian Andreo Halomoation Manurung has reported nine constitutional judges to the Constitutional Court Ethics Council (MKMK) regarding alleged ethical violations during the examination of Case Number 01/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026, which concerned the educational requirements of Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka.
The MKMK held a preliminary examination hearing for Report Number 05/MKMK/L/10/2026 at the Constitutional Court Building in Jakarta on Wednesday, with an agenda to hear testimony from the complainant and examine evidence.
Pian reported the nine constitutional judges presiding over the case due to suspicions that they violated several principles within the code of ethics and conduct for constitutional judges.
Pian, an advocate and Chairperson of the Indonesian Student Forum (Formasi), alleged that the judges violated the principle of independence as stipulated in Constitutional Court Regulation Number 09/PMK/2006 regarding the Declaration of the Code of Ethics and Conduct of Constitutional Judges, also known as Sapta Karsa Hutama.
“The alleged violators (the nine constitutional judges) have violated the principle of independence because Constitutional Court judges must perform their judicial functions independently,” said Pian, as quoted from the report published on the official Constitutional Court website.
The complainant also questioned the examination process of the PHPU case, alleging that there was pressure from the public, media, and political entities that influenced the trial proceedings.
Pian further linked these allegations to statements made by one of the PHPU petitioners, Denny Indrayana, regarding Gibran’s diploma.
“Constitutional Court judges should remain independent from pressure from society, the mass media, and the parties involved in a dispute that they must adjudicate,” Pian stated.
In addition to the principle of independence, the complainant suspects the nine constitutional judges violated the principles of competence and thoroughness in examining the case.
In the report submitted on 1 October 2026, Pian requested that the MKMK form an independent expert team, examine the alleged ethical violations objectively and neutrally, and impose heavy sanctions, including permanent dismissal, should the judges be proven to have committed ethical breaches.
The complainant also requested that the MKMK temporarily suspend the examination of Case Number 01/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026 until the ethical investigation is complete, and to annul any decisions or rulings made by the judges in that case.
However, following the submission of the report, the Constitutional Court issued its ruling on Case Number 01/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026 on Tuesday (6/10).
In its ruling, the Court stated that the petitioners’ application was inadmissible because the petitioners lacked legal standing.
Nevertheless, the Court stated it could not annul or disqualify Gibran from his position as Vice President because the petitioners lacked legal standing and Gibran no longer held the status of a vice-presidential candidate after being inaugurated on 20 October 2024.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/nine-constitutional-court-judges-reported-to-ethics-council-over-gibran-case-1791388826)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5775981/sembilan-hakim-mk-dilaporkan-ke-mkmk-terkait-perkara-gibran), translated from Indonesian