New Twist in Gibran Vice-Presidency Row: Resignation or Impeachment?
Eight factions in the House of Representatives (DPR) have reportedly agreed to use their right to issue a statement of opinion to follow up on the controversy surrounding Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s high-school diploma, on Tuesday (10 November).
This follows rulings by the Constitutional Court (MK) and the Supreme Court (MA) concerning the validity of his diploma and high-school equivalency certificate. Here are the latest developments in the debate over whether Gibran should resign, including his meeting with President Prabowo Subianto and the possibility of legal action.
Prabowo-Gibran meeting
State Secretary Prasetyo Hadi said Gibran met Prabowo at the Presidential Palace on Tuesday morning (10 November).
Prasetyo said that during the meeting, which reportedly lasted two and a half hours, Gibran expressed an intention to resign as vice-president.
“In that discussion, the vice-president, together with the President, did express his intention to resign in response to the developments surrounding the decisions by the MK and the MA,” Prasetyo told reporters.
Prasetyo stressed that Prabowo had not rejected Gibran’s intention to step down. He also said the President had offered his deputy advice.
“We would also like to clarify that it is not true that the President rejected that intention during the meeting. In the discussion, the President offered a great deal of advice,” Prasetyo said.
Gibran was subsequently reported to have asked for an opportunity to prove the validity of his documents through proceedings at the Administrative Court (PTUN).
Gibran speaks out
Gibran continued to carry out his duties as vice-president. On Tuesday (10 November), he accompanied Prabowo at a ceremony at the State Palace in Jakarta awarding the 2026 National Hero titles.
He also responded to reports that he would resign. While he did not explicitly confirm an intention to step down, Gibran said he respected public criticism and suggestions concerning the political developments, particularly the controversy over his diploma.
“I respect all the appreciation, criticism and suggestions from the public regarding the current developments. I do not want these developments to become a prolonged political controversy,” Gibran said at the Vice-President’s Office in Jakarta on Tuesday (10 November).
Minister Yusril weighs in
Coordinating Minister for Legal, Human Rights, Immigration and Corrections Affairs Yusril Ihza Mahendra gave his view on the legal action Gibran is reportedly considering over the validity of his diploma.
He said there would be little point in Gibran seeking to prove the documents’ validity through the Administrative Court, because the MK and MA rulings were final and binding.
“Nothing more can be done because the Constitutional Court’s decision is final and binding; there is no further legal recourse. The Supreme Court’s decision is also final, and no party can seek a judicial review of it,” Yusril said at the Presidential Palace in Jakarta on Tuesday (10 November).
Yusril explained that the defendant in the Supreme Court case was the Director General of the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education. Gibran could not appeal because he had not joined the case as an intervening defendant.
“Once it has been executed by the Minister of Primary and Secondary Education, as the superior of the Director General, the Supreme Court’s decision is also final,” he said.
He also raised the possibility that the Administrative Court case could be discontinued because the object of the dispute—Gibran’s equivalency certificate—no longer existed.
“In the case involving Ms Mercy and Mr Denny Indrayana, they joined as intervening defendants and could file an objection. But I think the final Supreme Court ruling, which was uploaded today, could lead the Administrative Court to halt the lawsuit brought by Ms Mercy and Denny Indrayana, because the object in dispute no longer exists,” Yusril said.
DPR members respond
Deddy Yevry Sitorus, a DPR member from the Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle (PDIP) faction, questioned Gibran’s move to address the diploma controversy through the Administrative Court.
“What does this have to do with the Administrative Court? It cannot overturn a Supreme Court ruling because they are in different jurisdictions. The Administrative Court deals with challenges to decisions made by state officials or the bureaucracy,” Deddy said in a statement on Tuesday (10 November).
Deddy said the plan to prove the validity of the equivalency certificate in the Administrative Court made little sense, as Gibran’s side and the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education had already had the opportunity to do so but had not taken it.
“So I see it as an attempt to buy time,” he said.
Meanwhile, DPR Deputy Speaker Saan Mustopa said he respected Gibran’s plan to take legal action.
“We should respect his right to do so,” Saan said.
However, Saan said the DPR could still proceed with the proposed political process under its right to issue a statement of opinion (HMP). He said Gibran’s Administrative Court case could therefore run in parallel with the DPR process.
Resignation need not be submitted through the President
Separately, Golkar deputy chairman and Commission II DPR member Ahmad Doli Kurnia said Prabowo did not need to approve Gibran’s resignation.
“Our Constitution does not say that a vice-president’s resignation must be submitted to the President for approval. There is no such rule,” Doli said at the parliamentary complex in Senayan, Jakarta, on Tuesday (10 November).
If Gibran wished to resign as vice-president, Doli said, the matter would be handled by the DPR and the People’s Consultative Assembly (MPR), not the President. He added that the DPR and MPR would not have the authority to reject Gibran’s resignation.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/new-twist-in-gibran-vice-presidency-row-resignation-or-impeachment-1794361934)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261111080936-32-1425698/babak-baru-nasib-wapres-gibran-usai-ungkap-niat-mundur), translated from Indonesian