Never-ending story
Never-ending story
The story of the House of Representatives' investigations of
alleged improprieties in the presidential palace, known as Bulog-
gate and Brunei-gate, is turning into a long-running and, one
might add, boring saga. President Abdurrahman Wahid, who has
refused repeated summons to testify in the investigations, has
now given a new twist to this story: he is questioning the
legality of the House's two special commissions which are
conducting the investigations.
The first investigation centers on the disbursement of Rp 35
billion rupiah from the employees foundation of Bulog, the state
logistics agency, to people close to the President. The second
centers on the President's failure to report to the treasury a
US$2 million donation from Brunei Sultan Hassanal Bolkiah.
The President, in spite of his repeated denials of any
wrongdoing in the two scandals, has been most uncooperative with
the investigations. By acting thus, he has ensured this saga,
which has added even greater uncertainty to the country's already
chaotic political situation, is prolonged longer than necessary.
Now the President has apparently uncovered another legal
loophole that gives him one more pretext not to answer the
House's summons to testify in the two investigations. He says the
two commissions were established under a 1954 law which was
enacted when Indonesia was ruled by the Provisional 1950
Constitution. Since the country reverted to the 1945 Constitution
in 1959, he insists the two commissions, which he claims were
never reported to the State Gazette, are illegal.
The President has now shifted the focus of attention away from
the substance of the investigations to the constitutionality of
the special commissions, and in doing so has shifted the burden
of proof from himself, as the subject of the investigations, onto
the commissions. Adding pressure to the commissions, most
constitutional law experts agree with the President in
questioning their constitutionality, and therefore the legality
and validity of their investigations.
The nation by now has become accustomed to the President's
resourcefulness in doing battle with his political foes,
particularly those in the House of Representatives and the
People's Consultative Assembly. The President, governing without
a popular mandate after his party won just 13 percent of the vote
in last year's general election, seems to have won every single
political battle so far. His latest claim that the special
commissions are constitutionally defective is another stroke of
genius on his part in outwitting his political foes who are bent
on unseating him.
This long-running political saga would have been palatable to
the nation if it was a mere TV melodrama, and not being played
out in real life in the halls of state. At least, if we were
bored with the storyline, we could switch channels.
Unfortunately, as boring as the story is, this is a real-life
drama, one with implications for the 210 million people of this
country.
The investigations have now become a battleground between the
President, who is fighting for his political survival, and his
foes, many of whom are the same people who secured his election
in October last year.
Aware that they have been constantly outwitted by the
President, many in the House are now considering a new
investigation: Borobudur-gate. This one is about a secret meeting
at the Borobudur hotel in Jakarta (hence the name) between the
President and Tommy Soeharto, shortly before the head of state
formally refused to grant a presidential pardon to the son of the
former president.
Bulog-gate and Brunei-gate are stories that were meant to be
told once and then put away, without the seemingly endless
sequels we now have. Both investigations could, and should, have
been resolved quickly for the sake of the nation.
If the President is as innocent as he claims, he should have
cooperated with the investigations and put the nation out of its
misery. By playing hard to get and prolonging the investigations,
the President has only increased speculation about his role in
the two scandals.
Whether the special commissions are unconstitutional, the
substance of the investigations remains important, and sooner or
later the President must answer for himself. If the President is
innocent, he should know that it is in the best interest of the
nation that he cooperate with the investigations and come clean
once and for all. If he is guilty of any wrongdoing, in the
interest of the nation he should allow the due process of the law
to be carried out and accept whatever fate awaits him.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/never-ending-story-1447893297-1286368)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post