Netanyahu Wins Without a Majority as Germany Hopes for a More Moderate Israeli Government
Two days after Israel’s parliamentary election, Berlin was still holding back. German officials and politicians were not yet ready to assess the result, as it remained unclear who would ultimately shape the direction of the country, a major ally.
The ultra-conservative Jewish coalition led by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu remained ahead of the opposition bloc rallied by former military chief Gadi Eisenkot. But its lead was not enough to secure Netanyahu a return to power. Neither side has a parliamentary majority, and the path to a new government is expected to be long and difficult.
Berlin’s caution was evident at a federal government press conference on Wednesday, 29 October. Martin Giese, spokesman for Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul of the Christian Democratic Union (CDU), declined to offer a political assessment of the Israeli election result.
He said only that Germany, through its ambassador to Israel, Alexander Graf Lambsdorff, remained in contact with all sides. “The Jewish state and Germany are bound by an inseparable history,” Giese said. “We will do everything possible to build good co-operation with whichever government is eventually formed.”
Alabali Radovan: “Winter in Gaza will be harsh”
Berlin’s concern is not only about who will take office in Israel. There is a more urgent issue: how people in the Gaza Strip will survive. Prolonged coalition negotiations could delay the delivery of humanitarian aid. Winter will not wait for a political agreement.
Germany’s Development Minister, Reem Alabali Radovan of the Social Democratic Party (SPD), raised the issue in an interview with Politico while visiting Lebanon. “Winter is approaching. Conditions will be harsh.” Humanitarian organisations must therefore be given greater access to Gaza. The needs of residents, she said, cannot be made dependent on when politicians finish negotiating and dividing up positions of power.
In interviews with DW and broadcaster RTL, she also addressed events in the occupied West Bank. “The violence by radical settlers must stop.” Netanyahu’s government, although now serving in a caretaker capacity, remains in office. The call to end the violence therefore still stands.
Growing distance from Netanyahu
Germany and Israel have traditionally enjoyed close relations. Those ties are rooted in Germany’s historical responsibility for the murder of millions of European Jews during the Nazi era. In recent years, however, the government in Berlin has increasingly distanced itself from Netanyahu’s policies, at least through more open criticism.
Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul (CDU), for example, previously criticised Israel’s large-scale military operation around the city of Hebron. “Under international law, Israel is clearly obliged to respect and protect the rights of Palestinians,” he said. The operation displaced around 3,000 Palestinians from their homes. Earlier, two Israeli soldiers had been killed by Palestinians.
Speculation has long been growing in Berlin about a possible change in Germany’s approach to Israel after the election. One thing remains clear for now: unlike some other countries, including several in Europe, Germany has no intention of recognising a Palestinian state. At the same time, Berlin hopes that religious politicians, some of them far-right, such as Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich, will not be part of the next government.
Hoping for a moderate government
The hope was expressed by Jürgen Hardt, a foreign policy expert for the CDU in Germany’s parliament. “In my view, the best thing for Israel would be to form a government closer to the centre of the political spectrum,” he told DW.
“Of course, that decision lies with the people and, above all, with the politicians who have been elected. But the high voter turnout is an encouraging development. Israel is a vibrant democracy—the only one in the region—and we must continue to emphasise that.”
In this Israeli election, several parties led by Arab Israelis recorded a considerable increase in support. Those parties are generally aligned with the opposition. Bundestag Vice-President Omid Nouripour of the Green Party told DW that “the major campaign by Netanyahu’s camp, aimed primarily at Arab Israelis, actually mobilised many people” to vote.
He said the prime minister’s sharp criticism had encouraged more Arab Israelis to go to the polls, and described this as good news for Israeli democracy.
Jürgen Hardt even raised the possibility of a minority government led by Gadi Eisenkot, supported by parties with Arab Israeli voters as their base. The CDU politician, however, set one condition: those groups must reject all forms of terror against Israel.