Negative Covenant: The Limits on Entrepreneurs' Actions After Obtaining Financing
When a company obtains a credit facility, attention usually focuses on the loan amount, interest, tenor, and repayments. However, once the funds are disbursed, the company’s room for manoeuvre is not always the same as before. Banks provide financing based on certain conditions, for example regarding assets, cash flow, capital structure, ownership, governance, and repayment capacity, which are expected to be maintained throughout the credit tenor. Therefore, credit agreements may contain negative covenants, which are the debtor’s commitment not to take certain actions or not to do so without the creditor’s approval.
Negative covenants create a ‘contractual fence’ against actions that could increase the creditor’s risk. By regulation, a company indeed has the right to change directors or commissioners, sell assets, take on new debt, provide guarantees to other creditors, distribute dividends, or carry out corporate actions. However, if the agreement requires the bank’s consent, such actions can constitute a default. Thus, the decision is legally valid but becomes defective under the contract. Consequently, what entrepreneurs need to scrutinise is not only ‘What is allowed by law?’ but also, ‘What is permitted under the contract?’
Negative covenants are not a legal requirement for a valid credit agreement. These clauses arise from the parties’ agreement based on the principle of freedom of contract under Article 1338 of the Indonesian Civil Code. Their function is to maintain the conditions that formed the basis of the creditor’s risk assessment and to support the principle of prudential banking. In practice, these clauses can restrict the transfer of material assets, additional indebtedness, granting security to other creditors (negative pledge), changes in directors, commissioners or controlling shareholders, mergers, consolidations, acquisitions, dissolution, certain affiliate transactions, and dividend payments that could reduce repayment capacity.
The degree of restriction depends on the value and tenor of the financing, the risk profile, corporate structure, type of assets, and business needs. Therefore, negative covenants must be proportional and not a templated list of prohibitions. Although the term is most often associated with bank credit agreements, the concept is much broader and can be found in various types of commercial contracts.
It is important to distinguish between legal prohibition and contractual prohibition. An action not prohibited by law may not necessarily be permitted by the contract. A debtor can legally take out new loans, sell assets, provide security, conduct affiliate transactions, or distribute dividends, but still commit a breach if the credit agreement prohibits or restricts it. Default is also not always limited to missed instalments. A debtor who pays on time can still be considered in default for violating a negative covenant. Therefore, it is crucial to examine the definition of default and the conditions that fall into that category, materiality, grace or cure periods, notice requirements, and the possibility of consent or waiver. Consequences can include warnings, remedial action, restructuring, acceleration, or legal steps in accordance with the agreement and applicable law.
Negative covenants bring together two competing interests: the bank’s need to control risk and the entrepreneur’s need for space to run the business. A clause that is too weak can endanger the creditor, while one that is too strict can act as a brake on growth. A balance can be built through materiality thresholds and carve-outs. A prohibition on asset transfers can exclude small transactions or those in the ordinary course of business. Restrictions on additional debt can provide room for operational debt within certain limits. Limitations on management changes can be focused on material changes, while affiliate transactions can be excluded if conducted at arm’s length and in the normal course of business. In this way, the bank remains protected without requiring every management decision to await creditor approval.
Before signing a credit agreement, entrepreneurs need to examine: (1) What actions are prohibited or require consent; (2) Whether the restrictions are too broad and hinder the ordinary course of business; (3) Whether there are carve-outs or thresholds; (4) What the consent procedure is and who is authorised to give it; and (5) What the consequences of a breach are, including events of default, cure periods, acceleration, or waiver. In a credit agreement, the figures are important: the facility amount, interest, tenor, and payments. However, the section explaining ‘what cannot be done’ can have an equal impact on business continuity. Negative covenants can determine whether the company remains free to take on new debt, expand, transfer assets, provide security, conduct affiliate transactions, distribute dividends, or make certain corporate decisions. Therefore, a credit agreement is not merely a document to obtain funds, but a rulebook that influences business decisions throughout the financing period. Before signing, entrepreneurs should not only ask, ‘How much money will I get?’ but also, ‘What am I not allowed to do after receiving the money?’
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/negative-covenant-the-limits-on-entrepreneurs-actions-after-obtaining-financing-1786596707)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20260813105953-14-758849/negative-covenant-batas-gerak-pengusaha-usai-mendapatkan-pembiayaan), translated from Indonesian