Nadiem Makarim Optimistic About Winning Appeal, Legal Team Highlights Alleged Judicial Ethics Violations
Former Minister of Education, Culture, Research, and Technology for the 2019–2024 period, Nadiem Anwar Makarim, has expressed optimism about facing the appeal hearing in his case at the High Court. This confidence is based on his assessment that the elements of the criminal act of corruption he was charged with were not proven in the first-instance trial.
Speaking after the appeal hearing at the DKI Jakarta High Court on Wednesday (5/8), Nadiem asserted that the case against him does not fulfil the elements of abuse of authority, unlawful acts, or state losses. “Our case is very strong. If even one of these three elements is not proven, it should result in an acquittal. In this case, none of them exist. There is no state loss, no unlawful act, no abuse of authority, nor conflict of interest,” he said.
He also revealed that his legal team had previously reported alleged pressure on the panel of judges who examined the case at the District Court level to the Judicial Commission (KY). He expressed hope that the ongoing internal reform process within law enforcement agencies would guarantee the judges’ independence in deciding the case at the appeal level. “We hope the judges can be independent, only following the trial facts and their conscience. That is what makes me far more optimistic,” he stated.
Nadiem’s legal counsel, Dodi S. Abdulkadir, stated there were indications of ethical code violations during the first-instance trial process. According to him, several pieces of evidence and trial facts were not considered in the verdict, providing a crucial reason for the appellate judges to re-examine the case. “It has been proven that there were indications of ethical code violations by the judges at the first-instance court. The trial facts that were not considered need to be re-examined by the appellate judges,” Dodi said. He added that confirmation from the Judicial Commission regarding these indications further strengthens the defence team’s belief that the first-instance ruling had fundamental problems.
Nadiem also described the case against him as a form of criminalisation. He argued that the indictment was built more on narrative than on the legal facts revealed during the trial. “Almost none of the elements of corruption exist factually, yet the ruling was based on narrative. There is no state loss and no flow of funds, but it is being forced into a corruption case,” he said. Nadiem noted that similar patterns have emerged in several other cases that have recently drawn public attention and stressed that the ongoing law enforcement reform must be strengthened to prevent such practices from recurring.
Meanwhile, another member of Nadiem’s legal team, Ari Yusuf Amir, confirmed their readiness to face the appeal filed by the public prosecutor. He stated that a counter-memorandum of appeal has been submitted and that there is no new evidence to strengthen the previous ruling.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/nadiem-makarim-optimistic-about-winning-appeal-legal-team-highlights-alleged-judicial-ethics-violations-1786002688)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/918939/nadiem-makarim-optimistis-menang-banding-kuasa-hukum-soroti-dugaan-pelanggaran-etik-hakim), translated from Indonesian