Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Myth or Fact: Men Use Logic, Women Follow Their Hearts

| Source: Antara (Indonesian) Translated from Indonesian | Anthropology
Myth or Fact: Men Use Logic, Women Follow Their Hearts
Image: Antara (Indonesian)

Jakarta (ANTARA) – The stereotype that “men use logic, while women rely more on their feelings” is a familiar one in society.

The phrase is often heard in everyday life, particularly when people discuss romantic relationships. When a man is thought to be too aloof, people may say men are simply more rational. Conversely, when women are seen as more easily swayed by their feelings, this is often described as a natural female trait.

But is it true that men rely more on logic while women rely more on their hearts?

The answer is that this idea is better described as a myth when it is used to characterise all men and women.

Psychological research shows that men and women have many similarities in a range of abilities and psychological traits. Differences identified in studies are not always substantial and can be influenced by context, environment, experience and upbringing.

So where does the idea that men use logic and women use emotion come from?

A common misconception is that men tend not to feel emotions.

In fact, men experience a range of emotions, including sadness, fear, disappointment, anxiety, anger and happiness. However, the ways people recognise, express and manage emotions can differ.

A review of research on emotion regulation and gender found differences in strategies for managing emotions, but also stressed that understanding of how men regulate their emotions remains incomplete.

This means that a man who appears calm does not necessarily lack feelings. He may simply have a different way of expressing or managing them.

The same applies to the assumption that women always follow their hearts.

Women may, of course, make decisions based on emotion, but that does not mean they do not use logical reasoning.

In everyday life, a person’s decisions are usually the result of a range of considerations. Experience, available information, circumstances, personal goals and emotions can all play a part.

It is therefore an oversimplification to assume that every decision made by a woman is based on feelings.

Logic and emotion are often portrayed as opposites. Yet they can work together in the decision-making process.

For example, when choosing a partner, someone may consider more than romantic feelings. Other factors might include shared values, communication style, financial circumstances, life goals and how the partner treats them.

Feelings can signal what someone considers important, while rational thought helps them assess the consequences of a decision.

For this reason, relying on feelings does not automatically mean being irrational.

Psychologist Janet Shibley Hyde, through her Gender Similarities Hypothesis, concluded from a review of dozens of meta-analyses that men and women have more in common across various psychological variables than popular culture often suggests.

She also explained that the extent of gender differences can vary depending on age and the context in which an ability is measured.

In other words, it is not appropriate to infer someone’s character simply from whether they are a man or a woman.

A man may be highly sensitive and quick to pick up on changes in other people’s emotions. A woman, meanwhile, may be highly analytical when making decisions.

Although the stereotype that “men use logic, women follow their hearts” is too simplistic, this does not mean that research has found no differences at all in particular areas.

Some studies have identified differences in emotion-regulation strategies. One study of older adults, for example, found that women in its sample scored higher than men on emotion regulation. However, findings of this kind must be understood in the context of the study and cannot be used to conclude that all women are better at managing emotions than all men.

This is an important point: average differences in research are not rules that apply to every individual.

How someone expresses emotions is not related to sex alone.

Family environment, culture, social circles, life experience, education and norms about how men or women “should” behave can all help shape behaviour.

For example, a boy who is repeatedly told from childhood that “men must not cry” may learn to hide his sadness. As an adult, he may appear to find it harder to express his emotions.

That does not mean he has no emotions; rather, he may have learned to express them differently.

Gender stereotypes can become a problem when they are used to excuse someone’s behaviour in a relationship.

For example, a man who rarely communicates with his partner may be considered unproblematic because “men are just insensitive”. Or a woman who needs reassurance may be dismissed as excessive because “women are too emotional”.

Relationship problems should instead be considered in terms of each person’s behaviour.

Is the partner willing to communicate? Do they respect their partner’s feelings? Can both people resolve problems without belittling one another?

Questions like these are far more useful than simply blaming gender differences.

So, who relies more on logic?

If the question is whether men are naturally more logical and women naturally more emotional, there is no simple answer that supports this assumption.

Men and women are equally capable of rational thought and of experiencing emotions.

There are some average differences in particular psychological aspects, but they are not sufficient to make gender a measure of someone’s personality.

Ultimately, everyone has their own way of making decisions and managing feelings.

More from 12 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/myth-or-fact-men-use-logic-women-follow-their-hearts-1791798861)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5781993/mitos-atau-fakta-pria-pakai-logika-perempuan-pakai-hati), translated from Indonesian
Print