Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

MUI Fatwa Chief Explains Why Vapes and Cigarettes Have Different Rulings

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Social Policy
MUI Fatwa Chief Explains Why Vapes and Cigarettes Have Different Rulings
Image: Republika

JAKARTA — The Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI) recently issued MUI Fatwa No. 131 of 2026 on the use of electronic cigarettes (REL), or vapes. The decision, which forbids the entire vape supply chain, from production and trade to use, immediately prompted discussion and a wave of questions among the public, particularly on social media.

In response, MUI Fatwa Chief Prof KH Asrorun Ni’am Sholeh gave a detailed explanation during a weekly religious study session examining Nashaihul Ibad, a work by Sheikh Nawawi al-Bantani.

Ni’am highlighted the many templated questions circulating on social media, often asking why conventional cigarettes and electronic cigarettes have different legal statuses. Some members of the public have questioned why tobacco cigarettes are subject to differing rulings, such as makruh (disliked) and forbidden, while vapes have been categorically declared forbidden.

In response, Ni’am said the conditions and scientific facts concerning the two products were very different. “While there is still room for scholarly disagreement over conventional cigarettes, there is no such room for disagreement over electronic cigarettes, because they have been scientifically proven to cause widespread harm and pose a danger to health,” Ni’am said, as quoted by Republika from the MUI Digital website on Sunday (15 November 202[6]).

Ni’am also addressed the economic argument made by some parties, concerning the contribution of vape excise to state revenue.

Based on direct coordination with the Directorate General of Customs and Excise at the Ministry of Finance, he said, the high excise imposed on vapes is not intended to generate state revenue. Instead, it is meant to limit access to the products. “With the existing excise, prices can automatically be much higher, making vapes less accessible,” Ni’am said.

More from 15 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/mui-fatwa-chief-explains-why-vapes-and-cigarettes-have-different-rulings-1794757858)
Originally published by Republika (https://khazanah.republika.co.id/berita/tojujo483/ketua-mui-bidang-fatwa-akhirnya-bicara-mengapa-hukum-haram-vape-dan-rokok-berbeda), translated from Indonesian
Print