MUI East Java Urges Police Action Following Fatalities Caused by 'Sound Horeg' Carnivals
The Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI) of East Java is urging the police to take decisive action against the organisation of ‘sound horeg’ carnivals following the deaths of three people due to these activities throughout August 2026.
KH Ma’ruf Khozin, Chairman of the MUI East Java Fatwa Commission, stated that the previous fatwa issued by the MUI only addressed the impact of ‘sound horeg’ regarding damage to residential houses and village infrastructure. He noted that the current situation has become far more serious as it has resulted in loss of life.
“When the MUI fatwa was issued, it was followed up by a Governor’s Circular (SE), and the field execution by the Regional Police (Polo) has been quite good. However, the impact is now much larger; it is causing casualties,” said Kiai Ma’ruf on Tuesday (1/9).
Ma’ruf stated that the police are now the ones capable of addressing this issue. MUI East Java hopes that the authorities will conduct a thorough investigation and resolve the cases involving the three deaths caused by ‘sound horeg’.
“Therefore, it should be dealt with more strictly. We truly hope this rests with the police. We at the MUI merely provide the fatwa; field execution remains within the domain of the police,” he said.
Ma’ruf also highlighted the trend of ‘sound horeg’ carnivals, which are likely to continue through the upcoming New Year celebrations. He warned that if not regulated immediately, the number of fatalities could continue to rise.
“Especially since the August festivities are still in full swing, and celebrations will likely continue until the New Year in December. If not regulated, our citizens will continue to repeat these actions. If there is no oversight, we only anticipate problems after they occur. This involves lives, and life is highly protected in religion. There have already been three victims, yet there has been no action,” he remarked.
Ma’ruf also encouraged the Governor of East Java to promptly issue a Governor’s Decree to ban ‘sound horeg’ activities. He argued that such a regulation would be more binding than the Circular (SE) previously issued.
“A Circular is not particularly strong. A Regional Regulation (Perda) takes a long time because it involves the council. Perhaps a Governor’s Decree is needed. In some cities, I am grateful that Mayors and Regents have maintained order. However, it cannot be denied that some officials may have existing ties with ‘sound horeg’ entrepreneurs, as these sound systems were used as campaign tools during the election period,” he said.
Ma’ruf added that in certain areas where officials are suspected of having ties to ‘sound horeg’ entrepreneurs, an official ban from the regional head is unlikely to be issued. Therefore, he emphasised that the responsibility for enforcement remains with the police.
“In places where no Circular or Regent’s Decree is issued, it remains the police’s domain. Once again, we hope the Governor handles the policy of prohibition, but the execution remains with the police. We must act before more lives are lost, as even though August has passed, these carnivals are still ongoing,” he said.
Previously, three people died in incidents related to ‘sound horeg’ in East Java throughout August 2026. The first victim, SN (29), a crew member from Jember, died on 2 August after hitting his head on a village gate in Arjasa District.
The second victim, Bonari (44), a resident of Banyuwangi, died from a suspected heart attack while participating in a ‘sound horeg’ parade on 23 August. The third victim, Slamet Timbang (57), a farmer from Jember, died after a canopy and an apothecary wall collapsed, allegedly due to the intense vibrations from the sound systems.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/mui-east-java-urges-police-action-following-fatalities-caused-by-sound-horeg-carnivals-1788274730)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260901190717-20-1398877/mui-jatim-minta-polisi-bertindak-usai-sound-horeg-makan-3-korban), translated from Indonesian