MUI Calls for Return to 'Manistaṭā'a' Principle in Hajj Financing
The Vice Chairman of the Indonesian Uability Council (MUI), Cholil Nafis, believes that the Hajj financing scheme needs to return to the principle of ‘manistaṭā’a ilaihi sabīlā’, which refers to the obligation of Hajj for Muslims who are capable.
“Those who depart for Hajj are ‘manistaṭā’a ilaihi sabīlā’,” said Cholil Nafis when confirmed from Jakarta on Wednesday, responding to proposed Hajj costs and financing schemes submitted by the government for the 2027 Hajj season.
Through the Ministry of Hajj and Umrah, the government has proposed the 2027 Hajj Organising Cost (BPIH) at Rp107.34 million per person, an increase from the previous year’s cost of Rp87.4 million. To maintain the affordability of costs paid directly by pilgrims, the Ministry proposed a financing scheme consisting of 60 per cent from the investment returns managed by the Hajj Financial Management Agency (BPKH) and 40 per cent from the Hajj Travel Cost (Bipih) paid purely by the prospective pilgrims.
Kiai Cholil stated that the term ‘subsidy’ in Hajj costs is actually inaccurate because the funds used do not originate from the government budget, but rather from the development of initial deposits made by prospective pilgrims during their waiting period.
“In reality, there is no subsidy in the Hajj costs, because it belongs to the individual. Therefore, the development process during the waiting list period belongs to them. Once a virtual account is used, there is no subsidy,” said Kiai Cholil.
He believes that the current distribution of Hajj fund development returns needs to be reviewed to ensure greater fairness for all prospective pilgrims, including those still in the queue for departure.
“The term ‘subsidy’ used now is not from the government, but from the total profit-sharing which is given mostly to those departing for Hajj. Meanwhile, those who are not departing—those on the waiting list—receive very little. Thus, the fairness of the distribution does not emerge,” he said.
“So, there is actually no such thing as a subsidy. Return it to those who are capable; for those who are unable, Allah does not mandate them to perform Hajj,” he emphasised.
Echoing Kiai Cholil, Anwar Abbas, an observer of social, economic, and religious issues and Vice Chairman of the MUI, stated that the obligation to perform Hajj for a Muslim is closely linked to the issue of ‘istithaaah’ (capability), involving health, material, and mental readiness.
“Therefore, it is best that everyone performing Hajj should bear all the costs of the pilgrimage they are undertaking. There should be no term of being subsidised or assisted,” he said.
According to Anwar Abbas, this clarification is important to ensure that prospective pilgrims do not take something that is not their right, including from the government’s side, considering the managed funds belong to the pilgrims.
“We know that the investment returns obtained from the management of Hajj deposit funds, after expenses are deducted, belong to the parties who have paid the Hajj deposits. Therefore, if the government takes it, they must have the permission of the prospective pilgrims who are not yet departing,” he added.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/mui-calls-for-return-to-manistataa-principle-in-hajj-financing-1783511806)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5640987/mui-pembiayaan-haji-perlu-dikembalikan-pada-prinsip-manistaa), translated from Indonesian