MUI Calls for Hajj Costs to Reflect 'Manistata'a' Principle, Rejects Subsidy Label
Deputy Chairman of the Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI), Cholil Nafis, has said that the hajj financing scheme should be returned to the principle of manistaṭā’a ilaihi sabīlā — the obligation of hajj for Muslims who are able to undertake it.
“Those who go on hajj must be those able to afford it,” said Cholil Nafis when contacted in Jakarta on Wednesday, responding to the proposed hajj costs and financing scheme put forward by the government for the 2027 hajj season.
The government, through the Ministry of Hajj and Umrah, has proposed a Hajj Organising Cost (BPIH) of Rp107.34 million per person for 2027, an increase on the previous year’s cost of Rp87.4 million.
To keep the costs directly paid by pilgrims affordable, the ministry proposed a financing scheme comprising 60% from the returns on funds managed by the Hajj Financial Management Agency (BPKH) and 40% from the pure Hajj Travel Cost (Bipih) paid by prospective pilgrims themselves.
Kiai Cholil said the term ‘subsidy’ in hajj costs is in fact a misnomer, because the funds used do not come from the government budget, but rather from returns generated on the initial deposits of prospective pilgrims during the waiting period before departure.
“In truth, there is no subsidy in hajj costs, because the money belongs to the pilgrims themselves. So the returns generated during the waiting list period belong to them. Once virtual accounts are used, there is no subsidy at all,” said Kiai Cholil.
He argued that the distribution of returns on hajj funds needs to be reviewed so that it is fairer to all prospective pilgrims, including those still queuing for their turn to depart. “The term subsidy used today is not from the government, but from the overall returns that are given mostly to those who actually go on hajj.
Meanwhile, those on the waiting list who have not yet departed receive very little. So the fair distribution of returns does not materialise,” he said. “So in reality there is no such thing as a subsidy. Return to the principle that only those who can afford it should go, for Allah does not oblige those who cannot afford it to perform hajj,” he stressed.
Echoing Kiai Cholil, a social, economic and religious affairs observer who is also MUI Deputy Chairman Anwar Abbas said the obligation to perform hajj for a Muslim is closely tied to the question of istithaa’ah — capability in terms of health, material means and mental readiness.
“Therefore, ideally every person performing hajj should bear all the costs of the pilgrimage themselves. There should be no such thing as being subsidised or assisted,” he said.
According to Anwar Abbas, this emphasis is important so that prospective pilgrims do not take something that is not rightfully theirs, including from the government, given that the managed funds belong to the pilgrims.
“We know that the returns obtained from managing hajj deposit funds, after costs are deducted, belong to those who have paid the deposits. Therefore, if the government takes them, it must be with the consent of the prospective pilgrims who have not yet departed,” he said. (Ant/P-3)
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/mui-calls-for-hajj-costs-to-reflect-manistataa-principle-rejects-subsidy-label-1783515045)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/humaniora/908860/ongkos-haji-diminta-dikembalikan-pada-prinsip-manistaaa-ini-penjelasannya), translated from Indonesian