Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Muhammadiyah's Manhaj Tarjih in the Midst of Modern Challenges

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Social Policy
Muhammadiyah's Manhaj Tarjih in the Midst of Modern Challenges
Image: Republika

The passage of time brings new challenges for the Muslim community. The way people work has changed, technology is increasingly intertwined with daily life, and the social problems that emerge are ever more diverse. These conditions have influenced the way Muslims view many things, from the digital economy to humanitarian issues that were rarely discussed in the classical context.

Amid these changes, a simple question arises: how can Islamic teachings remain relevant when social reality continues to change?

Answering this question requires more than a literal reading of the text. Religious texts are of course always the primary foundation, but reality also demands a broader reading.

It is for this reason that the Manhaj Tarjih of Muhammadiyah holds an important position. Muhammadiyah attempts to present a religious approach that remains rooted in the Qur’an and As-Sunnah, yet does not close itself off from the developments of the age.

This approach means that tarjih is no longer understood merely as choosing the stronger evidence. Its function has developed further, such as becoming a framework of thought for answering new problems faced by the Muslim community.

What Is the Manhaj Tarjih of Muhammadiyah?

Linguistically, tarjih means to strengthen or to choose one opinion considered stronger than others.

In the Islamic scholarly tradition, the term was originally associated with comparing evidence or the differing views of ulama. Its purpose was simple: to find the most robust argumentation among several sources.

However, within Muhammadiyah, the meaning of tarjih has developed. Tarjih no longer stops at the act of choosing an opinion. It is positioned as part of ijtihad, the intellectual process of reading social and humanitarian issues through an Islamic perspective.

In other words, tarjih does not only concern existing law, but also how Islam responds to new situations in the world.

Through its Majlis Tarjih and Tajdid, Muhammadiyah continually strives to ensure that religious decisions do not stop at readings of the past alone.

The Main Pillars of the Manhaj Tarjih of Muhammadiyah

A Comprehensive Understanding of Religion

For Muhammadiyah, religion is not understood merely as individual ritual. Islam is viewed as a system of values that guides human life comprehensively, encompassing not only one’s spiritual relationship with God, but also social behaviour, ethics, education and economic activity.

This view allows religion to be present in a broader space. Religion does not stop at the mosque or the prayer room, but also shapes the way a person thinks and acts.

The Spirit of Tajdid

Muhammadiyah is well known for the idea of tajdid, or renewal.

However, this renewal does not mean changing the basic teachings of a religion. Tajdid is better known as an effort to preserve the purity of the faith while presenting new responses to social issues.

On the one hand, there is a spirit of purification: keeping acts of worship in accordance with the guidance of the Prophet. On the other hand, there is a drive towards dynamism, allowing social and muamalah matters to develop in line with the needs of the age. These two go hand in hand.

An Understanding of Tolerance

Differences of opinion within Islam are nothing new. Since the classical era, differences of opinion have been part of the Islamic intellectual tradition. For this reason, Muhammadiyah does not regard the results of tarjih as the only truth that everyone must accept.

Differences are instead understood as space for discussion. As long as the argumentation is clear and conducted ethically, the diversity of viewpoints remains respected.

It is this approach that makes the face of Islam feel more mature.

An Understanding of Openness

The results of ijtihad are essentially a product of human thought. This means they are not absolute. Muhammadiyah recognises that social conditions continue to change and that knowledge also develops.

Therefore, tarjih decisions remain open to criticism and evaluation. If a stronger argument is found, or a new context demands adjustment, such corrections can be made.

Ijtihad, in this sense, is understood as a living process.

No Affiliation with a Particular Madhhab

Muhammadiyah does not bind itself exclusively to one particular madhhab.

That said, this does not mean rejecting the views of classical ulama. The opinions of various madhhabs are still studied and taken into consideration.

The focus is not on who holds the opinion, but on how strong the argumentation is and whether it is relevant to the problem at hand. This approach provides greater room for manoeuvre.

Sources of Law in the Manhaj Tarjih of Muhammadiyah

Within its intellectual structure, Muhammadiyah continues to place the Qur’an and As-Sunnah as the primary sources. However, there is a rather distinctive term: As-Sunnah al-Maqbulah.

This term is used to affirm that hadith which can serve as the basis of law are not limited to sahih hadith alone, but also include hasan hadith that are accepted on scholarly grounds.

Meanwhile, dhaif hadith are generally not used as a basis, unless they meet certain conditions and do not contradict the Qur’an.

The Bayani, Burhani and Irfani Approaches in the Manhaj Tarjih of Muhammadiyah

One of the strengths of Muhammadiyah’s tarjih method lies in its use of three complementary approaches, namely:

The Bayani Approach

Bayani focuses on the text. The Qur’an and As-Sunnah are the primary basis for understanding law, particularly in matters of pure worship (ibadah mahdhah) such as prayer, fasting and zakat.

Because worship is ritual in nature, a solid textual foundation is essential.

The Burhani Approach

Unlike bayani, the burhani approach gives room to reason, logic and scientific knowledge. This approach is highly relevant for responding to contemporary issues, from the digital economy to health.

One example can be seen in the use of hisab methods and astronomy to determine the start of the Hijri month. This shows that religion and science need not be opposed to one another.

The Irfani Approach

Beyond text and reason, Muhammadiyah also considers the spiritual dimension through the irfani approach.

This approach emphasises purity of heart, depth of conscience and sensitivity to humanity.

The goal is simple: that legal decisions be not only logically correct, but also carry wisdom that can be drawn upon.

The Hierarchy of Norms in the Manhaj Tarjih of Muhammadiyah

Muhammadiyah does not immediately classify an issue as halal or haram. There is a structure of norms that is used.

First, fundamental principles such as tawhid, justice, equality and maslahah (public benefit). Second, general principles derived from those fundamental principles. Third, concrete norms used to answer legal questions in practice.

This structure keeps legal decisions robust, yet not rigid.

Legal Flexibility in the Manhaj Tarjih of Muhammadiyah

One particularly interesting aspect is the recognition that law can change according to circumstances. Of course, such change is not made arbitrarily.

There are conditions that must be met, such as the presence of a real maslahah, the matter falling outside the realm of pure worship, and no contradiction with definitive (qath’i) evidence.

An often-discussed example is the issue of female leadership.

Through analysis of the principles of justice and maslahah, Muhammadiyah has opened space for women to lead in the public sphere. This shows that ijtihad does not stop at a merely literal reading.

Why the Manhaj Tarjih of Muhammadiyah Remains Relevant Today

Fundamentally, Muhammadiyah’s tarjih system seeks to bridge two things: the revealed text, which is fixed, and human reality, which continues to change.

Amid rapid change, this model of ijtihad feels increasingly relevant.

Islam is not present to freeze life. On the contrary, it provides moral direction so that change continues to proceed within a corridor of values.

This is where Muhammadiyah’s strength is visible. The changing times are not seen as a threat, but as a challenge to be answered with mature and open thinking.

More from 17 July 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/muhammadiyahs-manhaj-tarjih-in-the-midst-of-modern-challenges-1784253129)
Originally published by Republika (https://retizen.republika.co.id/posts/771790/manhaj-tarjih-muhammadiyah-di-tengah-tantangan-modern), translated from Indonesian
Print