Muhammadiyah Cadres Challenge Religious Courts Law on Isbat and Hisab Method at Constitutional Court
The Constitutional Court (MK) held a preliminary hearing on Tuesday (9/6/2026) regarding a judicial review of Law Number 3 of 2006, which amended Law Number 7 of 1989 concerning the Religious Court. The lawsuit focuses on the constitutionality of the mechanism for the initial and final ‘isbat’ (verification) of Ramadan, which is deemed to discriminate against users of the ‘hisab’ (astronomical calculation) method.
The petition was filed by three Muhammadiyah members: Andri Sumarna, Muhammad Fajri Nur Rizky, and Rozak Daud. They are contesting Article 52A and its accompanying explanation within the Religious Court Law, arguing that it contradicts the 1945 Constitution.
Article 52A of the Religious Court Law states that religious courts provide ‘isbat’ for ‘rukyat hilal’ testimony in determining the start of months in the Hijri calendar. However, the petitioners highlighted the explanatory section of the article, which grants the Minister of Religious Affairs the authority to nationally determine 1 Ramadan and 1 Syawal based on ‘isbat rukyat’.
According to the petitioners, this legal construction results in the ‘rukyat hilal’ method receiving official state recognition, while the ‘hisab’ method they adhere to does not receive equal standing. This is viewed as creating legal uncertainty and discriminatory treatment in the practice of worship.
“The substantive difference between the body of Article 52A and the Explanation of Article 52A creates a norm inconsistency,” said Juanda, the petitioners’ legal counsel, at the Constitutional Court Building I, Jakarta.
Juanda explained that the explanation of an article should only serve as an interpretation, not add new norms or narrow the scope of the law. In this case, the explanation is considered to narrow the scope of the Hijri year specifically to Ramadan and Syawal, while adding authority to the Minister of Religious Affairs that is not explicitly contained within the main body of the article.
The hearing was presided over by the Chief Justice of the Constitutional Court, Suhartoyo, alongside panel members M. Guntur Hambar and Daniel Yusmic P. Foekh. During the proceedings, the judges provided several notes for the improvement of the petition.
Constitutional Judge M. Guntur Hamzah suggested that the petitioners sharpen their legal standing and strengthen the ‘posita’ (legal grounds) of the petition. Meanwhile, Daniel Yusmic requested that the petitioners be more precise in aligning the articles being challenged with the submitted ‘petitum’ (claims).
Chief Justice Suhartoyo specifically requested that the petitioners prove the actual loss experienced due to the norms in the Religious Court Law, particularly regarding the ‘hisab’ method in relation to the ‘isbat’ session. “Whether the ‘hisab’ method and the requirement for court determination for those witnessing ‘rukyat’ act as an obstacle for the petitioners to perform their worship? That is what must be detailed,” Suhartoyo emphasised. The Court has granted the petitioners time to amend their petition before the case proceeds to the next stage.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/muhammadiyah-cadres-challenge-religious-courts-law-on-isbat-and-hisab-method-at-constitutional-court-1781049058)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/humaniora/898823/kader-muhammadiyah-uji-materi-peradilan-agama-terkait-isbat-dan-metode-hisab-ke-mk), translated from Indonesian