Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Muhammadiyah Cadres Challenge Ramadan and Syawal Determination Rules at Constitutional Court

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Muhammadiyah Cadres Challenge Ramadan and Syawal Determination Rules at Constitutional Court
Image: Media Indonesia

Three members of Muhammadiyah have filed a lawsuit with the Constitutional Court (MK) against the regulations that have long served as the basis for determining the start of Ramadan and Eid al-Fitr nationally. They argue that the rules prioritise the ‘rukyat hilal’ (moon sighting) method and do not provide equal space for the ‘hisab’ method, which is also utilised by a portion of the Muslim community.

The petition was submitted by Andri Sumarna, Muhamad Fajri Nur Rizky, and Rozak Daud under Case Number 180/PUU-XXIV/2026, which commenced its hearing at the Constitutional Court on Tuesday (9/6).

The petitioners are challenging the Explanation of Article 52A of the Religious Courts Act. According to them, that specific part of the explanation does not merely clarify the article’s content but instead introduces a new norm that has the potential to create legal uncertainty.

The petitioners’ legal counsel, Juanda, stated that the explanation of an article should only function to clarify the norms already present in the main body of the law.

“The explanation of an article should only serve as an official interpretation of the norm within the body of the law, not as a basis for forming a new norm. The explanation must not expand, narrow, alter, or contain a disguised change to the substance of the law’s norm,” Juanda told the panel of judges.

He argued that the explanation of the article limits the authority of ‘itsbat rukyat hilal’ (moon sighting verification) solely to Ramadan and Shawwal, even though the primary article states it applies to the determination of the Hijri months in general. Furthermore, the petitioners believe the rule indirectly positions the ‘rukyat hilalu’ method as the primary basis for the government’s national determination of the Hijri months.

However, according to the petitioners, a segment of the Muslim community, including Muhammadiyah members, uses the ‘hisab’ method—based on astronomical calculations—to determine the start of the Hijri months. They contend that this situation prevents the ‘hisab’ method from receiving equal recognition from the state and could potentially lead to discriminatory treatment against the Muslim groups that adhere to it.

Consequently, they have requested the Constitutional Court to declare the Explanation of Article 52A of the Religious Courts Act unconstitutional and without binding legal force.

“To declare that the Explanation of Article 52A of Law Number 3 of 2006 regarding the Amendment to Law Number 7 of 1989 concerning Religious Courts contradicts the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia and has no binding legal force,” stated Auliya Khasanofa while reading the petition’s prayer.

During the preliminary hearing, the constitutional judges requested that the petitioners strengthen their arguments regarding the constitutional loss they have suffered due to the enforcement of the norm. Constitutional Judge M. Guntur Hamzah requested that the petitioners provide additional evidence showing a direct link between the contested regulation and their constitutional rights.

“That evidence must be completed to determine whether the petitioners have the legal standing regarding the norm being tested,” said Guntur.

He also questioned the petitioners’ argument that the rule violates religious freedom. “How can you say this contradicts Article 29, paragraph (2), when in fact it does not prevent religious freedom in practising your religion,” Guntur remarked.

Meanwhile, the Chief Justice of the Constitutional Court, Suhartoyo, requested that the petitioners explain in more detail how the existence of the ‘itsbat rukyat hilal’ mechanism by the religious courts could prevent them from practising their worship based on the ‘hisab’ method.

“Whether the ‘hisab’ method’s requirement for religious courts to issue a determination for someone witnessing the ‘rukyat’—so that it can be established by the court—acts as an obstacle for the petitioners to perform their worship, that is what must be elaborated,” Suhartoyo stated.

The Constitutional Court has granted the petitioners until 22 June 2026 to amend their petition before the case proceeds to the next stage.

More from 10 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/muhammadiyah-cadres-challenge-ramadan-and-syawal-determination-rules-at-constitutional-court-1781097629)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/899058/kader-muhammadiyah-gugat-aturan-penetapan-awal-ramadan-dan-syawal-ke-mk), translated from Indonesian
Print