Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

MTI Finds 13 of 21 Presidential Instructions Problematic, Citing Crisis in Governance

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Politics
MTI Finds 13 of 21 Presidential Instructions Problematic, Citing Crisis in Governance
Image: Republika

The Indonesian Transparency Society (MTI) has found that 13 out of 21 Presidential Instructions (Inpres) issued between January 2025 and April 2026 show indications of accountability problems.

Beyond mere statistics, MTI warns that these findings signal a deeper governance crisis: fundamental fiscal and institutional decisions are shifting from constitutionally regulated spaces to instructional instruments that operate almost entirely without oversight.

The issues raised by MMT lie at the heart of constitutional law. In a constitutional democracy, the State Budget (APBN) is established by law and implemented transparently, as mandated by Article 2/3 of the 1945 Constitution.

Ratification by the House of Representatives (DPR) is not a mere formality, but the critical point where the power to spend state funds is tested, deliberated, and held publicly accountable. MTI argues that this very mechanism is being hollowed out.

Doctrinally, a Presidential Instruction is merely an instrument for internal executive coordination. It does not sit within the hierarchy of laws and regulations, it should not establish norms that bind the public, and it cannot be challenged in the Constitutional Court.

However, since Presidential Instruction 1/2025, MTI has found that this administrative instrument has shifted into a directive containing substantive fiscal and institutional decisions.

Of the 13 problematic instructions identified, two are categorised as high-weight, three as medium-weight, and eight warrant close scrutiny.

MTI Executive Director, Ahmad Jilul Qur’ani Farid, stated that what is currently occurring is a shift from a state subject to the law to a state that uses the law to execute the will of power.

“What we are questioning is not just one or two policies, but a shift in the way the state functions,” he said in a statement in Jakarta on Tuesday (23/6/2026).

“Decisions that should arise from open deliberation in the DPR are now being established from an instructional desk. The procedures appear complete—the plenary gavel is still struck, the state gazette is still published—but the substance has already been predetermined in closed executive rooms,” said Jilul.

He emphasised that the most critical concern is not technical legal violations, but the normalisation of disregarding the fundamental principles of constitutional democracy.

He noted that once the substance of the State Budget shifts from the legislative arena to the instructional arena, the phrase ‘established by law and implemented openly and responsibly’ loses its meaning.

“All that remains is formality. And this does not stop with one administration. Without institutional correction, this mechanism will be available for reuse by the next administration, regardless of who the leader is,” he said.

He added that MTI places these findings within the context of a broader democratic decline. The Democracy Report 2026, published by V-Dem, has classified Indonesia as an electoral autocracy since 2024.

More from 23 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/mti-finds-13-of-21-presidential-instructions-problematic-citing-crisis-in-governance-1782233538)
Originally published by Republika (https://news.republika.co.id/berita/th272n320/mti-sebut-13-dari-21-inpres-bermasalah-ini-penjabarannya), translated from Indonesian
Print