MSCI Downgrades Indonesia's Capital Market Information Flow Rating to Negative
Index provider MSCI has downgraded its assessment of the information flow aspect of Indonesia’s capital market from positive to negative in its Global Market Accessibility Review 2026. MSCI stated the downgrade was driven by limited transparency in share ownership structures and indications of coordinated trading behaviour that disrupt fair price formation in the market. This condition is considered to hamper the ability of global institutional investors to assess the true level of free float and reduces the reliability of share prices as a reference for portfolio construction and index replication. “As a result of these conditions, the Information Flow criterion for Indonesia has been downgraded,” MSCI wrote in its report on Friday (19/6).
According to MSCI, the lack of transparency in share ownership data and trading activity impedes efficient price formation. The situation makes it difficult for global investors to accurately measure the portion of shares genuinely available for public trading in listed companies. In a section noting deterioration, MSCI lowered the Information Flow criterion rating from “+” to “-”. The downgrade reflects ongoing concerns regarding free float transparency and the effectiveness of the price formation mechanism in Indonesia’s capital market.
MSCI also highlighted that stock market information is not always available in English. Under the Equal Rights to Foreign Investors aspect, the availability of company information in English is considered uneven, potentially making it difficult for foreign investors to obtain adequate information. Additionally, on the Foreign Exchange Market Liberalization Level aspect, Indonesia is assessed as not having an efficient offshore currency market. MSCI also noted remaining restrictions in the domestic foreign exchange market, including the requirement to link foreign exchange transactions with securities transactions.
From a market infrastructure perspective, MSCI noted that overdraft facilities in the clearing and settlement process are not yet permitted for foreign investors. Meanwhile, on the transferability aspect, in-kind transfers of assets can only be carried out under certain conditions. Stock lending activities are permitted but limited to certain securities with a maximum contract period of 90 days. Short selling practices are also allowed, though still subject to several restrictions. MSCI added that indications of coordinated trading behaviour affecting price formation are not only found in Indonesia but have also been identified in Turkey, particularly in small-cap companies. Such practices are considered potentially disruptive to market efficiency and may increase trading volatility.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/msci-downgrades-indonesias-capital-market-information-flow-rating-to-negative-1781837429)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/ekonomi/902100/msci-turunkan-peringkat-information-flow-pasar-modal-indonesia-jadi-negatif), translated from Indonesian