Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Modern Warfare and the Imperative of Smart Deterrence for Middle Powers Like Indonesia

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Politics
Modern Warfare and the Imperative of Smart Deterrence for Middle Powers Like Indonesia
Image: Republika

The May 30–June 5, 2026, edition of The Economist features an extensive review regarding the changing face of modern warfare. Its main thesis is quite compelling: the nature of modern war has changed drastically. While drones, satellites, sensors, artificial intelligence, and precision strikes have made warfare increasingly destructive, advanced technology does not automatically make victory easier to achieve. On the contrary, war is becoming increasingly difficult to win politically.

This argument feels increasingly relevant when observing the Russia-Ukraine war. Russia entered with significant military strength and modern technology, yet the war has transformed into a protracted conflict that drains resources and creates new political pressures for Russia both domestically and abroad. Ukraine has also demonstrated that a combination of cheap drones, satellite intelligence, and Western technological support can withstand a militarily superior conventional force. A similar situation is visible in the US/Israel vs Iran conflict in the Middle East. Despite various precision strikes and high-tech operations, regional stability remains elusive because the conflict continues to produce widespread political and psychological impacts.

This phenomenon shows that military victory no longer automatically results in political victory. Even the most technologically advanced nations face difficulties when attempting to translate battlefield success into long-term stability. A nation may be able to destroy enemy targets, seize specific territories, or win numerous battles, but none of this necessarily ensures a swift end to the war or a stable political situation.

In many cases, modern technology actually makes conflicts longer. Cheap drones, precision strikes, cyber warfare, and technological adaptability allow weaker parties to persist and continue resisting. Consequently, war transforms into a prolonged conflict that exhausts the economy, energy, logistics, and political resilience of both sides.

In articles titled “Smarter Tech Is Making War a Dumber Choice” and “Modern War”, The Economist concludes that modern war is now easier to start, but increasingly difficult to end.

However, the critical question remains: have great powers truly learned to be more cautious and avoid war after witnessing these changes in modern warfare?

Not necessarily. Stephen Walt, a professor of international relations at Harvard University, even wrote in Foreign Policy (2 March 2026) that the United States remains “addicted to war”. This does not mean all US leaders crave conflict, but rather that the structure of Washington’s power—a combination of military superiority, the military-industrial complex, and the belief that America must always “do something”—ensures that military options remain an attractive option in every international crisis.

As a result, despite the experiences in Afghanistan, Iraq, and now Iran demonstrating the limitations of using military force, the reflex for intervention remains strong in US foreign policy. Modern technology often creates the illusion that war can be conducted quickly, precisely, cheaply, and with minimal political cost. In reality, the situation on the ground is often far more complex and uncontrollable.

Russia also appears not to have learned the same lesson. What Moscow has learned from Ukraine is how to adapt to long-term warfare: increasing drone production, strengthening electronic warfare, deepening the defence industry, and transitioning the economy into a war economy. In other words, Russia is learning how to fight more effectively, not how to avoid war.

China is also studying modern warfare seriously, particularly in the context of Taiwan. Beijing seems to understand that an amphibious invasion of Taiwan would be extremely costly and risky. However, the lesson drawn does not necessarily mean a reduction in coercion. Instead, China is becoming more active in developing gradual military pressure, grey-zone operations, cyber warfare, and demonstrations of strength around Taiwan and the South China Sea.

Therefore, the world seems to be entering a paradoxical situation. Many great powers understand that modern war is becoming more expensive, harder to control, and more difficult to yield clear political victories. Yet, this awareness does not automatically lead them to avoid war. On the contrary, great powers continue to race toward developing new military technologies and strengthening their defence capacities for fear of falling behind their rivals.

In such a situation, the lessons for middle powers like Indonesia are vital. Indonesia has neither the interest nor the capability to involve itself in the war politics of great powers. With its vast archipelagic geography and limited defence budget, Indonesia needs to build a defence that is smart, defensive, and relatively inexpensive.

This means Indonesia does not need to pursue offensive warfare capabilities far abroad like the great powers. What is more important is building defensive capabilities that make anyone think twice before infringing upon Indonesian sovereignty. In modern warfare, deterrence is no longer primarily determined by the number of tanks, large ships, or expensive fighter jets. What becomes decisive is the ability to impose high costs on an adversary through adaptive, dispersed, and difficult-to-neutralise defence systems.

Consequently, Indonesia’s defence strategy needs to be more oriented towards maritime denial and an archipelagic “porcupine” strategy. Indonesia does not have to become a major offensive power, but it must become a nation that is difficult to pressure from both sea and air. The focus should not be on long-range strike capabilities, but rather…

More from 5 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/modern-warfare-and-the-imperative-of-smart-deterrence-for-middle-powers-like-indonesia-1780628013)
Originally published by Republika (https://analisis.republika.co.id/berita/tg4yx0393/middle-powers-di-era-perang-modern), translated from Indonesian
Print