Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Modern or Conventional Circumcision: Which Is Better?

| Source: Antara (Indonesian) Translated from Indonesian | Social Policy
Modern or Conventional Circumcision: Which Is Better?
Image: Antara (Indonesian)

Jakarta (ANTARA) – Circumcision is a common medical procedure for boys. With advances in health technology, the choice of methods has grown. Whereas conventional techniques were once the main option, parents can now also consider modern approaches such as clamps, Plastibell, electrocautery (often called “laser circumcision” in Indonesia) and staplers.

Modern methods are claimed to make the procedure more practical and quicker, with less bleeding. But are these technologies really better than conventional methods?

Before deciding, parents need to understand the differences, benefits and risks of each method.

Conventional circumcision uses a scalpel or specialised scissors to remove the foreskin. Once it has been removed, the doctor usually stitches the remaining skin with medical sutures.

Modern circumcision, meanwhile, uses specialised devices or technology to assist with foreskin removal and control bleeding. Some of the better-known methods include:

  • Clamp method: a specialised clamp holds the foreskin in place during the procedure.

  • Plastibell method: a plastic ring is placed around the foreskin and falls off after the tissue dries.

  • Electrocautery: electrical energy generates heat to cut tissue and help stop bleeding.

  • Stapler method: a specialised device removes the foreskin and helps close the wound.

It is worth noting that the term “laser circumcision”, commonly used in Indonesia, generally refers to electrocautery, not a medical laser that uses light energy.

One advantage of the conventional method is that it has been used for a long time and has extensive clinical experience behind it. Doctors can also tailor the removal of the foreskin to each patient’s anatomy.

In addition, the method does not depend on specialised clamps or staplers, making it an option at a range of healthcare facilities.

However, the procedure requires precision in both cutting and stitching, and may take longer than some modern methods. Bleeding during the procedure must be controlled using appropriate surgical techniques.

Modern methods offer several practical advantages, particularly in terms of speed and bleeding control.

A systematic review and meta-analysis published in the Journal of Pediatric Urology in October 2025 compared conventional circumcision with device-assisted methods in children.

The study, which included 23 studies and 23,490 patients, found that device-assisted methods involved shorter operating times, less post-operative bleeding and fewer repeat operations.

However, the research found no significant differences in several other complications, including wound infections, swelling and delayed healing.

Modern methods also have drawbacks. They require specialised equipment, may cost more, and not every device is suitable for every child’s anatomy.

Some techniques also carry specific risks, such as swelling with plastic clamps or tissue injury if electrocautery is used incorrectly.

So, which method is better for a child?

No single circumcision method can be considered best for every child. The choice should take into account the child’s age, health, penile anatomy and the experience of the doctor performing the procedure.

Parents should also avoid being swayed solely by claims that circumcision will be painless or heal fastest. Every method still requires appropriate anaesthesia and aftercare.

Make sure the procedure is performed by a qualified doctor or medical professional at a healthcare facility with adequate equipment.

More from 15 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/modern-or-conventional-circumcision-which-is-better-1794714764)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5855103/sunat-modern-vs-sunat-konvensional-mana-yang-lebih-baik), translated from Indonesian
Print