Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Mitigating 60 Per Cent of Hajj Costs from BPKH: Ensuring Fair, Safe, and Sustainable Hajj Funds

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Finance
Mitigating 60 Per Cent of Hajj Costs from BPKH: Ensuring Fair, Safe, and Sustainable Hajj Funds
Image: Republika

Discussions regarding who should bear the Hajj Organising Costs (BPIH) resurface every season during the cost-setting period. When it is proposed that 60 per cent of the BPIH be mitigated from the Hajj Financial Management Agency (BPKH), the most honest public question is: is this fair, safe, and sustainable for the 5.8 million pilgrims still in the queue?

The answer to that question cannot be found through a populist approach of low costs. It must be grounded in legal, Sharia, and sustainability foundations. It is at this point that the BPKH hopes the Hajj cost determination meets three eternal principles: fair, safe, and sustainable.

Fairness: In Accordance with Law and Fatwa

Fairness in the management of Hajj funds is clearly outlined in Law No. 34 of 2014 concerning Hajj Financial Management. Article 10 letter (f) and Article 16 paragraphs (1), (2), and (3) provide an unambiguous mandate: the BPKH is responsible for managing the benefits of Hajj deposits by distributing those benefits periodically to the virtual accounts of Hajj pilgrims based on a percentage approved by the House of Representatives (DPR).

This means that the investment benefits are an individual right. They are not a collective cash pool that can be withdrawn at will to cover the departure costs of certain groups. These benefits must return to their owners, whether they are departing this year or are set to depart in 26 years, proportionally and transparently.

This principle of fairness is reinforced by the Decision of the Ijtima’ Ulama of the Indonesian Fatwa Commission Number 09/Ijtima’ Ulama/VIII/2024 regarding the Law on Utilising Investment Returns from Initial Hajj Deposits of Prospective Pilgrims to Finance the Hajj Organising of Other Pilgrims. The fatwa confirms: utilising the investment returns from the initial deposits of waiting pilgrims to finance pilgrims who are departing is prohibited.

Therefore, when the mitigation of 60% of the BPIH is charged to the BPKH without distinguishing between the rights of departing pilgrims and the rights of waiting pilgrims, it becomes a mode of cross-subsidisation that violates Sharia—a forced seizure of the rights of those in the queue for the sake of departures. This is an intergenerational injustice among Hajj pilgrims that we must avoid.

The conclusion of the Working Group Meeting (RDP Panja) of Commission VIII of the DPR RI on 15 February 2023 also provided a guideline: there is a need for periodic rationalisation policies for Hajj Travel Costs (Bipih) in accordance with economic conditions. The goal is precisely to maintain the principle of fairness for waiting pilgrims and the long-term sustainability of Hajj funds. Rationalisation means restructuring the proportions, not increasing the burden on investment benefits to the point of eroding the rights of waiting pilgrims.

More from 16 September 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/mitigating-60-per-cent-of-hajj-costs-from-bpkh-ensuring-fair-safe-and-sustainable-hajj-funds-1789538325)
Originally published by Republika (https://analisis.republika.co.id/berita/tlfxlr366/mitigasi-60-persen-bpih-dari-bpkh-menjaga-dana-haji-adil-aman-dan-abadi), translated from Indonesian
Print