Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Ministry of Religious Affairs: AI Lacks a Teacher, Scholarly Lineage, and Moral Responsibility

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Social Policy
Ministry of Religious Affairs: AI Lacks a Teacher, Scholarly Lineage, and Moral Responsibility
Image: Republika

The rapid development of Artificial Intelligence (AI) will not be able to replace the human role, particularly in the formation of character, etiquette, and Islamic scholarly traditions.

The Director of Islamic Religious Information at the Indonesian Ministry of Religious Affairs, Muchlis M. Hanafi, emphasised that AI is merely a tool that lacks a ‘sanad’ (chain of transmission), teachers, or moral responsibility.

“AI can help find verses, hadiths, tafsir books, or scholars’ opinions in seconds,” said Muchlis during the Scientific Oration for the XIX Akhirussanah Graduation of Santri at Pondok Pesantren Al-Qur’aniyyah at the SC STAN Building, Bintaro, South Tangerang, on Sunday (21/06/2026).

However, according to Muchlis, AI does not possess a sanad, does not have a teacher, lacks spiritual experience, and does not bear moral responsibility for the answers it provides.

In an oration titled ‘From Scholarly Tradition to Civilisation: Becoming a Qur’anic Generation in the Era of Artificial Intelligence’, Muchlis emphasised that in the Islamic tradition, knowledge is not merely about the correctness or incorrectness of information, but also involves who teaches it, how the knowledge is acquired, and the values and etiquette that accompany it.

“In the Islamic tradition, knowledge is not just about correct information, but also about who teaches it, how it is obtained, and the values and adab (etiquette) that accompany it,” he stated in his remarks to Republika.co.id in Jakarta on Wednesday (24/06/2026).

Therefore, according to Muchlis, the presence of AI can indeed assist the learning process and expand access to knowledge, but it will never replace the role of teachers, scholars, and the ‘talaqqi’ tradition, which has been a hallmark of Islamic knowledge transmission from the era of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) to the present day.

He also reminded that technological advancement must not cause the younger generation to lose their passion for learning and dedication to knowledge.

More from 24 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/ministry-of-religious-affairs-ai-lacks-a-teacher-scholarly-lineage-and-moral-responsibility-1782302012)
Originally published by Republika (https://khazanah.republika.co.id/berita/th4vv4320/kemenag-ai-tak-punya-guru-sanad-dan-tanggung-jawab-moral), translated from Indonesian
Print