Minister Pigai Clarifies President's Remarks Regarding Experts Acting as Buzzers
Human Rights Minister Natalius Pigai has explained that the President of the Republic of Indonesia’s criticism regarding the phenomenon of “experts” was not aimed at all scientists or specialists. He noted that the President had even used harsh language to describe the perceived absurdity of certain experts’ intelligence.
“What the President means are groups of people who hold various overlapping positions. Intellectual groups and experts who also act as activists, buzzers, influencers, haters, supporters of Party A, supporters of Party B, or members of interest groups,” Pigai stated during a press conference in Jakarta on Tuesday (22/09/2026).
Pigai explained that this phenomenon is visible on social media, where individuals with specific academic backgrounds are labelled as experts, yet simultaneously serve as partisans, influencers, or supporters of specific political factions.
He argued that this condition must be distinguished from scientists or experts who present views based solely on their academic capacity. Pigai emphasised that the President’s statement was not intended to generalise all scientists or experts.
“So, it does not apply to everyone. As I mentioned, there is one individual who is widely recognised as a professor and a doctor of constitutional law. However, they were previously a minister, then a member of the House of Representatives for a political party, then a leader of a high-state institution, then an activist, then a candidate for national leadership, and now a social media manager,” he said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/minister-pigai-clarifies-presidents-remarks-regarding-experts-acting-as-buzzers-1790124954)
Originally published by Republika (https://news.republika.co.id/berita/tlsjwo484/menteri-pigai-jelaskan-maksud-presiden-ri-pakar-merangkap-buzzer), translated from Indonesian