Military Judges: No Intelligence Operation Behind Andrie Yunus Attack
The panel of judges at Military Court II-08 Jakarta has concluded that there was no intelligence operation behind the acid attack on Andrie Yunus, the Deputy Coordinator of External Affairs at KontraS, by four members of the TNI Strategic Intelligence Agency (BAIS) Headquarters Detachment.
Based on the legal facts revealed during the trial, the judges stated that the defendants carried out the acid attack due to resentment following Andrie’s interruption of a meeting regarding the TNI Bill at the Fairmont Hotel in March 2025, intending to teach him a lesson.
The defendants identified are Defendant I Sergeant Edi Sudarko, Defendant II First Lieutenant Budhi Hariyanto Widhi, Defendant III Captain Nandala Dwi Prasetyo, and Defendant IV First Lieutenant Sami Lakka.
“It is true that the perpetrators, who emotionally do not know the victim but harbour resentment and grudge against him, fall under the theory of vicarious trauma,” said member judge Navy Major M. Zainal Abidin during the verdict reading at the Garuda courtroom of Military Court II-08 Jakarta on Wednesday (10/6).
Vicarious trauma is a condition of stress or emotional trauma that arises from frequently hearing, seeing, or being exposed to the traumatic stories and experiences of others.
The judge explained that an intelligence operation is not a spontaneous act, but is instead systematically designed and based on the strategic objectives of the state. Intelligence operations, the judge clarified, are not built upon personal anger but on the calculation of national interests.
“It is true that in military intelligence doctrine, an intelligence operation is not a spontaneous or emotional act, nor is it carried out individually without a command structure. Military intelligence operations are activities designed to be systematic, hierarchical, measurable, and based on the strategic objectives of the state,” the judge stated.
“It is true that in the world of intelligence, there is an important principle that intelligence is a tool of the state, not a tool of emotion. Strategic intelligence operations are not built upon personal anger, but upon the calculation of national interests,” he continued.
On this basis, the judges held that to label an action as an official intelligence operation, it must be proven to have strategic national objectives, orders or authorisation, a command structure, operational planning, operational system support, implementation control, an evaluation mechanism, and accountability.
If these elements are not met, it is difficult to categorise an action as an official military intelligence operation. “Without these elements, it is very difficult, both professionally and doctrinally, to refer to an action as an official military intelligence operation,” the judge remarked.
In this regard, the judge also referenced the testimony of strategic intelligence expert, Rear Admiral TNI (Ret.) Soleman B. Ponto, who was called to the trial. The judge noted that the expert stated that if an action exhibits personal emotion and irregularity, it serves as an indicator that it is not an official intelligence operation of an institution.
“The panel of judges, in this instance, bases its opinion on that expert’s testimony, asserting and believing that the Defendants’ actions had no connection to the involvement of a command structure,” said the judge.
The judge imposed prison sentences on the four defendants in this case. Defendant I Sergeant Edi Sudermako was sentenced to 3 years in prison; Defendant II First Lieutenant Budhi Hariyanto Widhi was sentenced to 2 years and 6 months; Defendant III Captain Nandala Dwi Prasetyo was sentenced to 2 years; and Defendant IV First Lieutenant Sami Lakka was sentenced to 1 year and 6 months.
Defendants I and II acted as the executors who physically poured the acid on Andrie. The judge took into account the degree of fault and the nature of the actions of Defendants III and IV to impose lighter sentences, despite them holding higher ranks than the other two defendants.
Furthermore, the judge imposed additional penalties on Defendants I and II in the form of dismissal from military service.
“The court orders that the Defendants remain in detention,” the judge declared.
The Defendants were found to have violated Article 467, paragraph 1 in conjunction with paragraph 2, and Article 20, letter C of Law Number 1 of 2023 regarding the Criminal Code (KUHP). This article regulates premeditated assault, with maximum prison sentences of 4 years (paragraph 1) and 7 years (paragraph 2).
The verdict is not yet legally binding (inkracht) as the Prosecutor and the Defendants have stated they will use the 7-day period to consider their options.
The case was presided over by the panel chairman, Colonel Chk Fredy Ferdian Isnartanto, with members Navy Major M. Zainal Abidin and Lieutenant Colonel Kum Irwan Tasri. The Clerk was Lieutenant Chk Rekika Bangun. The Prosecution was led by Major Chk Mohammad Iswadi and others.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/military-judges-no-intelligence-operation-behind-andrie-yunus-attack-1781081929)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260610143525-12-1367513/hakim-militer-tak-ada-operasi-intelijen-di-kasus-andrie-yunus), translated from Indonesian