Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Military Court Paradigm to Change Following Constitutional Court Ruling

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Military Court Paradigm to Change Following Constitutional Court Ruling
Image: detikcom

The Constitutional Court (MK) has granted a petition challenging the Military Courts Law, ordering lawmakers to change the jurisdiction of military courts.

The petition, case number 260/PUU-XXIII/2025, was filed by Lenny Damanik and Eva Meliani Br Pasaribu. Lenny is the mother of MHS, a 15-year-old junior secondary school pupil who died after being assaulted by Sergeant Riza Pahlivi. Eva is the daughter of journalist Rico Sempurna Pasaribu, who was burned to death in Karo.

The petitioners challenged Article 9(1), Article 43(3) and Article 127 of Law No. 31 of 1997 on Military Courts against Article 1(3), Article 24(1), Article 27(1) and Article 28D(1) of the 1945 Constitution.

The court granted the petition in full and ordered lawmakers to amend the Military Courts Law within a maximum of two years.

The full ruling states:

  1. The petitioners’ application is granted in its entirety.

  2. Law No. 31 of 1997 on Military Courts is declared conditionally contrary to the 1945 Constitution and without binding legal force unless it is amended within a maximum of two years from the pronouncement of this ruling.

  3. If lawmakers fail to amend the law within two years of the ruling, Law No. 31 of 1997 on Military Courts will be contrary to the 1945 Constitution and have no binding legal force.

  4. The ruling is to be published in the State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia as required.

The court’s reasoning

In its reasoning, the court said military jurisdiction over military offences is justified by the specific nature of the case, not simply by the defendant’s status as a member of the Indonesian National Armed Forces (TNI). Ordinary crimes committed by TNI personnel should be tried in civilian courts.

“Thus, the justification for military jurisdiction over military offences lies in the specific nature of the cases, not merely in the offender’s status as a soldier. In this context, the jurisdiction of civilian courts covers ordinary crimes, as provided for in the Criminal Code, committed by TNI personnel, and such cases should fall under civilian courts,” said Constitutional Court Justice Arsul Sani.

Justice Enny Nurbaningsih said there was no legal reason to retain military-court proceedings for ordinary crimes committed by soldiers in peacetime, or when civilian courts could operate normally. However, she said the court left room for ordinary crimes committed by TNI personnel in wartime combat zones to be tried in military courts. Any such restriction must be clearly regulated.

“Therefore, if an extension of military jurisdiction is needed to handle ordinary crimes committed by TNI personnel during wartime in combat zones, it must be specifically and narrowly formulated and may be provided as an exception,” Enny said.

The court also discussed the principle of impunity, in which offenders cannot, or are not effectively, held accountable. It said that the further an offence is from the specific character of military service, the weaker the grounds for retaining it under military jurisdiction.

“Limiting military jurisdiction is not intended to diminish the position of military courts as part of the judicial authority, but to ensure that their special jurisdiction is used only for cases that genuinely have a military character. Conversely, applying civilian courts to ordinary crimes committed by TNI personnel is consistent with the need to ensure accountability and independence, and to prevent the risk of impunity,” Enny said.

Full integration under the Supreme Court

The court also issued guidance for revising the law, saying military courts have yet to be fully integrated into the judicial system under the Supreme Court (MA).

“Besides the lack of clear definitions distinguishing military offences from ordinary crimes committed by TNI personnel, including the jurisdiction to try such offences, the court has also established as a matter of fact that the military courts have not yet been fully integrated as part of the judicial authority under the Supreme Court,” Enny said.

The court said military judges were not yet fully under the Supreme Court. According to the court, recruitment, appointments and career administration for military court personnel remained partly under the TNI commander.

“Of the court systems under the Supreme Court, the military courts alone have not fully relinquished recruitment, appointments and career-development administration for personnel, which remain under the TNI commander,” Enny said.

The court said full integration of military courts into the Supreme Court must be an important part of the amendments to Law No. 31 of 1997. It called for the integration to be included in order to establish a one-roof judicial system under the Supreme Court.

“Through this ruling, the court also affirms that this matter must form an important part of the amendments to Law No. 31/1997, which should provide for the integration in order to establish a one-roof judicial system, in keeping with the spirit of reform and the mandate of Law No. 4/2004, as amended by Law No. 48/2009,” Enny said.

TNI response

TNI Deputy Commander General Maruli Simanjuntak responded to the ruling by saying the armed forces would study the court’s decision calling for the Military Courts Law to be revised.

“We will discuss how far the process of this law has progressed. I have not been directly handling it, but I hope to study it going forward,” Maruli said at the State Palace in Jakarta on Thursday (15 October 2026).

Maruli also addressed criticism that trying soldiers in military courts leads to impunity. He said military courts had often imposed severe sentences on TNI personnel.

“In many cases, we have been stricter in dealing with criminal incidents. In the military, there have been repeated life sentences. I think that is rare elsewhere. If you look at the record, you can see how many times we have sentenced people to life imprisonment. In civilian courts, that is actually rare,” he said.

Maruli said military punishments were already severe, but stressed that he would first examine the ruling in greater detail.

“I think the rules in the military are actually much tougher. But there may be cases where, if we could follow the proceedings, we might understand why a violation appears to have occurred but the court imposed a lighter sentence. I will look into it in more detail,” he said.

Army Chief of Staff General Tandyo Budi Rivera said the TNI Army obeyed the Constitution and would follow whatever framework the state established.

“The military is subject to the Constitution. We follow what the Constitution says now, and we will follow whatever the state decides in the future,” Tandyo said.

He added that the Army would not be responsible for amending the law on its own. “The Army is not the only one responsible for changing it,” he said.

More from 16 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/military-court-paradigm-to-change-following-constitutional-court-ruling-1792111972)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8709339/paradigma-peradilan-militer-berubah-usai-putusan-mk), translated from Indonesian
Print