Militaristic Management and Investment Decisions: An Analysis of Risk Preferences
Companies with board members from a military background record a positive relationship with investment efficiency, indicating more optimal allocation of capital and resources. Through the lens of Upper Echelons Theory and Imprinting Theory, military training and experience shape context-sensitive risk preferences, discipline and accountability in strategic decision-making. Although military discipline has a positive impact, the presence of board members with a military background should still be balanced with technical financial expertise in order to maintain balanced governance and efficiency. This study provides comprehensive insight into the contribution of non-financial board qualifications to corporate financial decisions, along with practical implications for board recruitment, policymakers and businesses in emerging markets.
Method and Results
The study uses Indonesia as its research setting because of the unique civil-military dynamics following the enactment of Law No. 34 of 2004. The research sample covers 2,648 observations of non-financial companies listed on the Indonesia Stock Exchange from 2011 to 2019. The variables used include investment efficiency (measured using the Huang 2020 model) as the dependent variable, and the presence of board members with a military background as the independent variable. Control variables include firm size, leverage, firm age, property, plant and equipment (PPE), Big 4 auditors, Tobin’s Q, stock return, ROA volatility, cash flow volatility, board size and the presence of independent commissioners. To address endogeneity issues, the study applies Heckman’s two-stage regression, Coarsened Exact Matching (CEM), Propensity Score Matching (PSM) and the Generalized Method of Moments (GMM). The results show that the presence of military-background boards significantly improves company investment efficiency. This positive effect is mainly driven by R&D efficiency, companies experiencing overinvestment, military positions on the board of commissioners (BOC), and companies operating in industries with low military concentration. In addition, the improvement in investment efficiency is found to be significant for boards with backgrounds in the Indonesian Army (TNI AD), Navy (TNI AL) and Air Force (TNI AU). These findings confirm that discipline-based leadership and situational analysis stemming from a military background can minimise capital allocation errors and create long-term value for companies.
Detailed information about this research can be found in our paper at: https://doi.org/10.1108/JAL-11-2024-0333
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/militaristic-management-and-investment-decisions-an-analysis-of-risk-preferences-1788843026)
Originally published by unair.ac.id (https://unair.ac.id/manajemen-militeristik-dan-keputusan-investasi-analisis-preferensi-risiko/), translated from Indonesian