Menteng's Dark Past: Landowner's Son Jailed for Torturing Vagrant
The Menteng area is now synonymous with elite residential districts. Yet more than a century ago, the area was rocked by a scandal involving the family of its very own landowning ruler.
The figure in question is Said Ali bin Shahab, one of the wealthiest men and largest landowners in Menteng since around 1908. His standing as an influential figure was suddenly tarnished in 1908 after his family became embroiled in a case involving the torture of a vagrant.
The newspaper De Stichtsche Courant (26 March 1908) revealed that the main perpetrator was Said Ali bin Shahab’s son, Said Abdul Mutalib, along with an assistant named Entong.
The case began when the victim refused to pay levies to the landlord. During the colonial era, landowners held the right to collect levies from people living on their land, whether in the form of money or labour.
The refusal infuriated Abdul Mutalib. Together with his assistants, he had the victim seized and tortured.
“[…] With or without the landlord’s knowledge, the victim was taken at night by the son and other assistants and carried to a shed at a rural house, where they were bound and chained,” the newspaper wrote.
According to the newspaper’s report, Said Ali bin Shahab knew of the incident but did not stop it. When the case came to light, the victim’s body still bore marks of the bindings on his wrists and several other parts of his body. The news quickly spread throughout Batavia.
The police then arrested Abdul Mutalib and the assistants directly involved in the torture. Said Ali bin Shahab was also detained, as he was deemed to have allowed the criminal act to take place in his presence. They faced prison sentences of between two and five years.
After roughly nine months of legal proceedings, the court finally handed down its verdict.
“This Arab man, son of a landowner in Menteng, appeared before the district court for the unlawful imprisonment of a native resident and was sentenced to ten months’ forced labour without chains,” reported the Bataviaasch Nieuwsblad (5 November 1908).
Interestingly, whilst the legal proceedings were under way, the colonial government was negotiating the purchase of part of the Shahab family’s land in Menteng.
The plan covered the purchase of the land together with some 295 buildings at an agreed price of 1,310,000 guilders. The municipal government sought to control part of the privately owned land in Batavia for public purposes.
“The purpose of this purchase at a genuinely fair price is to acquire a plot of municipal land amidst all the private estates in Batavia, where, if necessary, a new cemetery could be built,” stated the Bataviaasch Nieuwsblad (20 July 1908).
In the end, the transaction went ahead. Once the legal case concluded, the Shahab family’s land officially passed to the municipal government. Several years later, Menteng was developed into a modern residential district for Batavia’s elite. That image as an elite neighbourhood persists to this day.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/mentengs-dark-past-landowners-son-jailed-for-torturing-vagrant-1785225118)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/entrepreneur/20260728092336-25-754319/wilayah-menteng-diguncang-skandal-anak-crazy-rich-siksa-gelandangan), translated from Indonesian