Megawati's presidency: Is sincerity alone enough?
Megawati's presidency: Is sincerity alone enough?
Mochtar Pabottingi, Senior Researcher, Indonesian Institute
of Science (LIPI), Jakarta
Unlike her predecessor, President Megawati Soekarnoputri
announced from the outset the seven priorities of her
administration; the first five are maintaining unity, continuing
reforms, rescuing the economy, upholding the law and clamping
down on corruption.
Her state addresses were commendable; the ones for the 56th
anniversary of independence; for her Cabinet lineup, and for the
annual budget announcement. She also performed well in Washington
and took the initiative of stating her belief in the necessity of
a constitutional commission.
In some respects, Megawati brings a degree of sanity back to
politics. She threw her party's weight behind Hamzah Haz in the
vice presidential election, rather than candidates from either
Golkar or the military. She did this despite the fact that Hamzah
was among the fiercest opponents of a woman becoming president.
She warned or denounced officials in local or provincial
governments (for imposing unwarranted taxes and levies and for
misusing development funds to purchase houses in Jakarta) as well
as recent anti-U.S. demonstrators for their insensitivity to the
nation's plight.
She also increased the budget for the armed forces, but told
them to continue revising their professionalism, to relinquish
involvement in practical politics, and to have more respect for
human rights.
On behalf of the nation, Megawati apologized to the Acehnese
and Irianese. We are not sure whether she was behind the move by
the Attorney General to challenge the Supreme Court decision to
free Tommy Soeharto, but there is no doubt that she gave her
consent for the office to investigate Akbar Tandjung's alleged
corruption.
To balance these positives, we can mention four instances of
the President's poor performance. A major disappointment was her
decision to appoint M.A. Rachman as the new Attorney General.
This was then coupled with her hitherto failure, as some
argue, to come up with a strategy to combat corruption, which
cast doubts as to her firmness in that regard.
Second, due to her lack of a proactive stance and reluctance
to take charge, she waited too long to respond to the anti-U.S.
demonstrations until considerable damage was done politically and
economically. Next, she was silent about the sharp increase in
the budget for foreign presidential trips.
And finally, indications showed that she was prone to enjoy
and cherish the "mother symbol" that merely caters to her
function as head of state, which is largely inconsequential.
Early on, President Megawati was criticized by many. Outside
observers dubbed her "a puppet president", beholden to both the
military and "the conservative forces" of President Soeharto's
regime (Far Eastern Economic Review, Aug. 2). She was accused to
be "an obstacle to reform" and "a compliant figurehead" under the
military and the police (Leslie McCulloch, The Jakarta Post, July
25). She was said to have repeated the mistakes of her father
with respect to "center-region relations" and "the politicization
of the armed forces" (R. William Liddle, the Post, July 31).
Under Megawati, "the kind of reformist agenda that was very
important under B.J. Habibie's and Abdurrahman's will be lost,"
the President's relationship with the military "will be stable,"
and Soeharto's model of a kitchen cabinet has been revived
(Takashi Shiraishi, the Post, Aug. 3).
Her alleged commitment to democratization and the rule of law
are seriously obstructed by the populist and authoritarian
tendencies she inherits from her father, wrote Angus McIntyre in
this newspaper on Aug. 15.
Domestic observers also attacked her weakness in the campaign
against corruption, collusion and nepotism (KKN), her lack of
focus and control, her failure to uphold the reform agenda, and
the absence of a clear strategy as to the direction of her
administration. They also questioned her commitment to press
freedom and civil society.
It is, I think, a bit too much to call President Megawati "a
compliant figurehead" or as merely a "puppet" beholden to
Soeharto's men. At least two of the three military officers
appointed in her cabinet have been her "supporters", even while
Soeharto was still in power -- a good relationship that continued
when Megawati was vice president.
As mentioned, she put her support behind Hamzah Haz in the
contest for vice presidency, rather than one of the two military
nominees or Akbar Tandjung. Against the seemingly concurrent
maneuver within both the police and military to extend the
official term of their highest chiefs, Megawati opted for the
rationality of succession, ignoring even any quid pro quo deal
with the former. Her insistence that the military should continue
revising its position toward professionalism is another
signal.
These are good points to counter the allegation that she is
falling under Soeharto's trap concerning "the politicization of
the military" or that she is steering the country back toward
authoritarianism. The fallacy of Professor Liddle's argument here
stems from the radical difference of stature between the military
prior and during the period of Guided Democracy and its post-
Soeharto counterpart, just like that between the context of
regional struggle during the 1950s and during these last four or
five years.
Her commitment to political reform, to civil society and to
clean governance was unmistakable in her call for a
constitutional commission and in the coherent moves of her and of
her party in the House to pursue Akbar's alleged corruption.
This is the appropriate time not to overlook the fact that she
was one of Sukarno's daughters. She certainly cannot be put
alongside the figure of Sukarno, but she must have grown with the
pride of her father, which has likely worked to prevent her from
becoming a mere puppet.
Another factor that hurried observations miss is the
possibility that the President will and perhaps has emancipated
herself politically during these last turbulent and exciting
years in her life and in the life of the nation.
It might be difficult to change her quiet demeanor, but we
need to appreciate the appropriate political steps she has taken
as we try to check whether that demeanor is prompted by an
unwillingness to take responsibility or fear of making big
political mistakes out of sincere love for her country.
Mattering much more than skill in articulation are sincerity
and integrity, personal qualities which the President evokes from
time to time. It is wise not to ignore her own words two weeks
following her call for the constitutional commission: "The
altered conditions compel us to reorganize and reinvigorate the
vision of our future, something that perhaps our own founding
fathers never envisioned" (the Post, Aug. 8).
The populist and authoritarian tendencies are no doubt at
stake with such a pronouncement, which is unlikely to have been
advised by the "Soeharto men" or New Order "conservatives" around
her.
I might be wrong with these contending arguments. There are
three fears in the back of my mind: That we tend to associate
Megawati's failure to deliver improvements in the economy with
poor political progress; that we have become too accustomed to
disparaging criticism and hurried conclusions during the last few
years; and that we might have deceived ourselves by thinking that
we can return to normalcy overnight, or that we are already
dealing with figures and personages of our choice, or that we
already have that choice, in the government.
Disappointed just like many Indonesians are with the
performance of President Megawati, measured against the depth of
our multidimensional crises, I have learned to temper my
expectations with questions such as the following: Did the
president appoint M.A. Rachman as the new Attorney General
because she surrendered to pressure, or as a tactical choice?
Have the economic "dream team" fallen far short of expectations
because of a communication breakdown between the team and the
President, or communication between the team members?
Do we have a better alternative than Megawati now, or would
Hamzah be the better successor? There must be many other delicate
questions like these. Unless we can be fully sure of the right
answers to them, we must learn to be patient and work hard toward
bettering what we presently have. Amien Rais's advice that, for
the moment we be proportionate in our criticism of our current
President is, accordingly, a wise one.
It would be encouraging to see the President really capitalize
on her commitment in not getting herself, her family, her party
and her Cabinet members involved in KKN. This would boost her
political clout and political capital, just as it would be
inspiring nationwide.
Courage and sincerity are of course essential. Thereafter, she
could replace all the bad elements that continually corrupt the
judicial institutions from the top and move on with confidence to
realize the seven priorities of her Cabinet.
The President, in concert with her party's faction in the
House, should therefore staunchly see to it that Akbar Tandjung's
case is thoroughly examined by both the Attorney General's Office
and a special committee in the House. The President should ignore
Golkar's threat to fight back, for the correct political gain
exceedingly outweighs any offensive that the New Order bastion
could muster.
It would also magnify her political prestige nationwide if she
could step up her call for a constitutional commission envisaged
in her state address.
This is an updated version of a presentation delivered at the
Joint Forum on Indonesia, held by Singapore's Institute of
Southeast Asian Studies and Jakarta's Centre for Strategic and
International Studies, on Nov. 1 in Singapore.
More from 28 November 2001 โ
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/megawatis-presidency-is-sincerity-alone-enough-1447893297-1071482)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post