Mediation Deadlocked, Four Media Outlets Claim Togar's Lawsuit Threatens Press Freedom
Mediation in the Rp 25 billion civil lawsuit filed by advocate Togar Situmorang against four media companies has again failed to produce an agreement. The closed-door meeting held at the Denpasar District Court on Tuesday (4/8/2026) ended without any common ground between the two parties.
The defendants’ legal team, organised under the Bali Journalists’ Solidarity (Solidaritas Jurnalis Bali, SJB), stated they were unwilling to accept the points put forward by Togar. The plaintiff’s side, meanwhile, remained open to a resolution through a settlement mechanism.
Following the mediation, the defendants’ legal team of 34 advocates, coordinated by I Made ‘Ariel’ Suardana, assessed that there was nothing new on offer in the mediation summary submitted by Togar’s side.
They said the contents of the summary still revolved around the demands already set out in the lawsuit. In that suit, Togar requests three main things. First, compensation of Rp 25 billion. Second, the publication of clarifications and an apology. Third, the removal or take-down of all reporting that is the subject of the dispute.
“We have conveyed orally that we reject all of those demands. So there is no possibility of a settlement,” said one member of the defendants’ legal team.
The presiding judge as mediator then asked for the rejection to be submitted in writing. This step is required as part of the mediation process under Supreme Court Regulation (PERMA) Number 1 of 2016 on Mediation Procedures in Court.
The defendants argued that the substance offered in the mediation summary fell within the core of the lawsuit itself, making it difficult to treat as room for compromise.
“If the contents are the same as the lawsuit, what is there to settle? Not only those three points — not even zero-point-something per cent will we agree to a settlement,” he asserted.
The issue of the principal’s attendance
Beyond the substance of the suit, the mediation process was also marked by discussion of the principal’s attendance and the legal counsel’s authority to make decisions during mediation. A member of the defendants’ legal team, Wayan Sudana, said his side had prepared a special power of attorney for the purposes of mediation.
According to him, the letter grants the legal counsel authority to conduct the mediation process, including drafting the summary, providing responses, and accepting or rejecting settlement offers.
“The special power of attorney for mediation has been prepared in accordance with PERMA. It includes the authority to draft the summary, provide answers, and to accept or reject. So there is really no reason left to question the principal’s attendance,” Wayan explained.
He added that the defendants believed the summary submitted by the plaintiff should not have rehashed the core demands of the case. In his view, the mediation process ought to be directed towards finding an alternative resolution acceptable to both parties.
The presiding judge as mediator subsequently gave the defendants two days to provide a written response to the mediation summary submitted by the plaintiff.
Once the response has been handed over, the mediation result will be reported to the panel of judges to determine the next stage of the case.
Togar’s side asks the defendants to commit to a mediated settlement
Meanwhile, Togar Situmorang’s legal adviser, Jody Kunto, said his side had attended the mediation together with the principal in accordance with the regulations and had submitted the mediation summary to the mediator.
“We attended together with the principal in accordance with the mediation provisions under PERMA, and we respect today’s mediation agenda, so we attended and handed over the mediation summary directly,” Jody said.
According to Jody, the summary submitted to the mediator reflects Togar’s wishes as the party claiming to have been harmed in the case. Togar’s side, Jody continued, still hopes the matter can be resolved without going further into the substantive examination of the case.
“We certainly hope the defendants can commit to it so that this case can be resolved through a settlement, without abandoning the basic principles for which mediation is held,” he said.
Defendants link the case to press freedom
Meanwhile, the defendants stressed that their unwillingness to settle is not based solely on the value of the claim, which reaches Rp 25 billion. They view the case as having broader dimensions, as it concerns journalistic work and press freedom.
According to the defendants’ legal team, the demand for large-scale compensation accompanied by a requirement that all reporting be taken down could impact the freedom of the media in carrying out its social control function. From the outset, the defendants have described the case as an unjustified lawsuit against the press.
They also consider the case to have the characteristics of a Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation (SLAPP) — a lawsuit deemed capable of exerting pressure on parties carrying out public participation functions, including the media.
“This lawsuit does not only target four media companies. It concerns the interests of the entire press community. If today we choose to settle, there is no guarantee that tomorrow other media outlets will not face the same thing,” said I Wayan Sedana, a member of the legal team.
For the defence team, this legal process is also an opportunity to test the position of press freedom when confronted with a civil lawsuit. They hope the case can serve as a lesson on the importance of protecting journalistic work and the media’s function as an instrument of social control.
“We want this case to become an education in democracy as well as a moment to strengthen protection for press freedom in Indonesia,” he concluded.
With the mediation having failed to produce an agreement, the Rp 25 billion lawsuit now awaits the mediation result report from the presiding judge as mediator to the panel of judges. If it is declared that no settlement has been reached, the case will proceed to the substantive examination of the lawsuit at trial.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/mediation-deadlocked-four-media-outlets-claim-togars-lawsuit-threatens-press-freedom-1785826257)
Originally published by detikBali (https://www.detik.com/bali/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-8603613/mediasi-buntu-empat-media-sebut-gugatan-togar-ancam-kebebasan-pers), translated from Indonesian