MBG, Universities, and the Future of Academic Freedom
Feeding the younger generation is a sign of a nation’s care for its future. However, preserving freedom of thought on campus is how a nation maintains its dignity and the sustainability of its civilisation.
The Free Nutritious Meal (MBG) programme is one of the major agendas of the new administration to build the quality of Indonesia’s human resources. Morally, this programme is born from a noble intention: ensuring children have access to proper nutrition as a foundation towards ‘Indonesia Emas 2045’. From a public health perspective, nutritional intervention is proven to influence child development, learning capacity, productivity, and the quality of future generations.
However, as this programme begins to enter university spaces and is linked to direct campus involvement, more fundamental questions arise than mere budgetary technicalities. These questions touch upon the direction of higher education development, priorities for human resource investment, and the future of academic freedom in Indonesia.
Universities are not merely administrative institutions implementing state programmes. Campuses are intellectual spaces that maintain public rationality, develop science, and nurture the courage for critical thinking. Therefore, universities have a moral responsibility to pose critical questions to every public policy, including a programme as large as MBG.
Criticism of MBG should not be understood as an anti-people stance. On the contrary, academic criticism is necessary so that good programmes do not lose their precision, effectiveness, and sustainability. This is where the meaning of academic freedom lives: universities do not exist to justify all state policies, but to ensure that state policies remain tested by scientific reasoning.
The first concern is the potential disruption of campus independence. In many public policy practices, large government programmes are often followed by excessive mobilisation of academic support. Universities risk shifting from spaces of scientific evaluation to spaces of policy affirmation. In such a situation, higher education institutions no longer serve as guardians of objectivity but transform into instruments of legitimacy.
Yet, the essence of a university lies in freedom of thought, freedom of research, and the courage to criticise for the nation’s interest. When the space for criticism weakens due to political pressure, proximity to power, or programme dependency, then the university slowly loses its intellectual soul. History shows that advanced nations are born from a critical academic tradition. Universities are not merely implementers of government programmes, but strategic partners capable of testing policy effectiveness scientifically and independently. Therefore, university involvement in MBG should remain within academic corridors: conducting research, evaluation, supervision, and developing evidence-based models, rather than merely serving as a formality for policy.
The second concern pertains to the priorities of national higher education development. The public is justified in asking: when large budgets are directed towards MBG, is the state also providing equivalent attention to the strengthening of higher education?
Today, the world of higher education, particularly private universities, faces serious pressure. The number of new students in various private institutions is declining due to weakening public purchasing power, changes in educational preferences, and increased competition with state universities.
Data from PDDikti and BPS show that the number of higher education institutions in Indonesia has experienced a declining trend over the last five years, from approximately 3,166 institutions in 2020 to around 2,937 institutions in 2024. The majority of these institutions are private universities.
Several reports also indicate that small and medium-sized private universities in various regions are facing a crisis in new student intake. Many campuses struggle to maintain institutional sustainability because student enrolment is decreasing, while operational costs, the need for lecturers, laboratories, learning technology, and accreditation requirements continue to rise.
This issue should not be regarded merely as an internal campus problem. Private universities have played a significant role in expanding access to higher education for the public. When private universities weaken, access to higher education for lower-middle class groups and regional communities is also threatened.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/mbg-universities-and-the-future-of-academic-freedom-1780911078)
Originally published by Republika (https://analisis.republika.co.id/berita/tf86wu368/mbg-kampus-dan-masa-depan-kebebasan-akademik), translated from Indonesian