Marketplace Tax Collection Requires Strict Supervision to Be on Target
The mechanism for collecting Income Tax (PPh) Article 22 through marketplaces is deemed to require stricter supervision to ensure it reaches the intended targets. Tax observer from Pelita Harapan University (UPH), Ronny Bako, believes the government must not only ensure the collection system functions but also be capable of identifying businesses that truly hold Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprise (MSME) status.
According to Ronny, clarity regarding MSME criteria is fundamental before the policy is widely implemented. He noted that loopholes still exist, allowing large-scale businesses to exploit MSME status through third parties, potentially avoiding their rightful tax obligations.
“The criteria for every MSME actor must be clarified. In the field, we see wealthy individuals playing the MSME game by providing capital to certain individuals,” Ronny told Media Indonesia on Wednesday (1/7).
“Therefore, the beneficial owner (BO) of MSMEs must be transparent. Large players must not be allowed to use the MSME label by using proxies,” he added.
He emphasised that the primary principle of taxation policy is fairness. Consequently, the government must be able to distinguish between MSMEs that truly meet the criteria and businesses that merely use MSME status as a cover to obtain various facilities.
Furthermore, Ronny questioned the government’s readiness to detect all digital trade activities. He noted that transactions occur not only on official marketplaces but also through social media such as Facebook and various other digital platforms, which also require attention.
“The government must detect players in marketplaces, both official ones and unofficial ones, such as selling on Facebook and similar platforms,” he said.
Ronny also assessed that the transparency of transaction values is a crucial factor in supporting the effectiveness of tax collection. He proposed that the government appoint official banks, both state-owned and private, as means of recording transactions so that digital trade values can be monitored more accurately.
On the other hand, the government is urged not to focus solely on digital trade. He argued that the existence of traditional traders and businesses outside marketplaces must also be considered so that taxation policies do not cause negative impacts on business sustainability or potential layoffs.
Ronny added that the implementation of the PPh Article 22 collection policy also faces several technical challenges. In his view, Indonesia’s vast territory, uneven internet quality, and the potential for moral hazard could hinder the effectiveness of the policy’s execution.
Therefore, he believes the government needs to ensure infrastructure readiness and cross-ministerial coordination so that policy implementation runs optimally. Additionally, public education must be conducted from the outset, rather than after problems arise in the field.
Ronny also emphasised the importance of strong coordination between the Ministry of Finance, the Ministry of Communication and Digital (Komdigi), and relevant ministries and agencies, given that each possesses different authorities.
“The most important thing is how the government educates the public. The government should not wait for an incident to occur before reacting. Furthermore, it must be ensured that the Ministry of Finance, Komdigigu, and related ministries are coordinating well,” he said.
Furthermore, Ronny believes local governments should also be involved in the implementation of this policy. He argued that regions, as locations of community economic activity, should receive a certain portion of PPh Article 22 revenue through a revenue-sharing scheme so that the benefits of the policy can be felt more evenly while strengthening supervision at the regional level.
Separately, the Director General of Taxes at the Ministry of Finance, Bimo Wijayanto, emphasised that supervision is conducted by identifying business actors based on turnover, whether they have gross turnover below or above Rp500 million, as part of a more accurate tax administration system.
The supervision process also utilises data from the submission of Annual Tax Returns (SPT), for both individual and corporate taxpayers. The data received during the reporting period serves as a basis for the Directorate General of Taxes (DJP) to cross-match information.
Additionally, the DJP found that there are still several taxpayers with ‘dormant’ status who are detected having transactions through counterparties. This finding serves as an indicator for tax authorities to conduct further examinations regarding taxpayer compliance.
According to Bimo, the DJP is increasingly relying on data exchange with various ministries, agencies, local governments, and associations to perform information matching. This step is strengthened by the integration of the National Identity Number (NIK) and the Taxpayer Identification Number (NPWP), ensuring higher data accuracy.
“We usually detect it this way; the data exchange, which is already very effective with many institutions, government agencies, organisations, associations, and local governments, becomes our basis for cross-checking,” said Bimo.
Through this comparative data, the DJP can identify whether information voluntarily submitted by taxpayers is accurate or requires clarification. This approach is expected to improve the quality of supervision and strengthen voluntary taxpayer compliance.
Bimo assessed that the digital trade sector still holds significant potential for tax revenue. Based on DJP observations over the last five years, revenue from this sector has consistently increased, reaching Rp24 trillion.
Through the implementation of the new collection mechanism, the DJP hopes that the level of taxpayer compliance will increase, followed by improved collection accuracy.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/marketplace-tax-collection-requires-strict-supervision-to-be-on-target-1782903058)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/ekonomi/906323/-pemungutan-pajak-marketplace-perlu-pengawasan-ketat-agar-tepat-sasaran), translated from Indonesian