Managing Rimba Raya: Commercialisation and Governance of Mountain Climbing
Long queues of climbers in danger zones or near mountain summits are no longer a phenomenon unique to Mount Everest in the Himalayas. In Indonesia, similar scenes regularly appear on social media and in national news coverage. Reports from the Ministry of Environment and Forestry (KLHK) and the Central Statistics Agency (BPS) record a drastic surge in the number of visitors to conservation areas, particularly national parks with volcanic mountain destinations.
Between 2018 and 2023, the number of domestic tourist visits to national park areas jumped by more than 150 percent, reaching over 7.8 million visits at the peak of the post-pandemic climbing season. Mount Gede-Pangrango, Merbabu, Rinjani, and Semeru now accommodate tens of thousands of climbers each month. The phenomenon of mountain climbing’s popularity, driven by outdoor recreation trends, social media exposure, and the commercialisation of climbing tour packages, has transformed Indonesia’s mountains from spaces of contemplation and limited adventure into commodities of mass tourism.
Behind the promising economic figures, there are concerning ecological and social disruptions. Data from the Secretariat of the Indonesian National Committee for UNESCO and forestry ecology research show that carrying capacity pressure on main climbing routes has exceeded safe thresholds. Accumulation of plastic waste, devaluation of edelweiss vegetation, pollution of springs due to poor sanitation, and fatal accidents involving untrained climbers have become daily consequences of overly lax management.
According to statistical reports from Basarnas, during the 2020–2023 period there was a 35 percent increase in Search and Rescue (SAR) operations in Indonesia’s mountainous regions, with more than 60 percent of cases caused by physical unpreparedness, lack of standard equipment, and minimal navigation knowledge among climbers. This indicates a gap between the explosion of public interest and the maturity of risk governance and inclusive conservation systems.
Commercialisation of outdoor activities fundamentally provides significant contributions to local economies. Bank Indonesia and the Central Statistics Agency record local economic growth around popular mountains—such as the Malang-Lumajang area (Semeru), North Lombok (Rinjani), and Cianjur-Sukabumi (Gede Pangrango)—supported by ecosystems of porter and guide service providers, equipment rentals, accommodation, and culinary SMEs. Studies by the World Tourism Organization (UNWTO) show that adventure and nature tourism generate economic value retention of 65 percent at the local level, far higher than conventional tourism which often experiences economic leakage to foreign entities or large corporations.
However, when commercialisation proceeds without strict and transparent regulation, the commodification of nature gives rise to the ‘tragedy of the commons’ as theorised by Garrett Hardin (1968). Mountains are positioned as public goods whose resources are exploited exhaustively without clarity on who is responsible for their restoration.
A study report by the Ministry of National Development Planning/Bappenas on the Green Economy warns that damage to mountain ecosystems due to overtourism creates negative externality losses that exceed Non-Tax State Revenue (PNBP) income from entrance tickets. Soil degradation due to erosion on main climbing routes, loss of habitat for rare fauna such as the Javan leopard and Javan hawk-eagle, and damage to the hydrological function of water catchment areas are long-term burdens that must be borne by future generations.
This fragility is exacerbated by PNBP tariff-setting schemes and retribution distribution that are not yet fully equitable for conservation. Most revenue enters the state treasury without an adequate earmarking fund mechanism for trail maintenance, climber education, and strengthening of field management units. As a result, national parks often operate with limited forest police personnel and operational budgets, while the number of people requiring supervision has multiplied dozens of times over.
Facing this governance crisis, the conventional approach of reactively closing trails during disasters or waste accumulation is no longer sufficient. A paradigm transformation is needed from reactive management to integrated science- and technology-based governance.
The implementation of online booking-based climbing quota systems in several national parks is a positive initial step. However, these quota systems are often based on rigid administrative decisions rather than transparently published scientific calculations of physical, ecological, and social environmental carrying capacity (Real Carrying Capacity and Effective Carrying Capacity).
Scientific research from the Harvard Business Review on vulnerable destination management emphasises the importance of digital technology interventions to monitor carbon footprints and visitor movements. The use of Internet of Things (IoT) sensors, RFID-based tracking on climber wristbands, and Geographic Information System (GIS) mapping can control trail density in real-time. This technology also serves as a safety mitigation instrument, accelerating SAR response times during emergency conditions or when climbers go missing.
Beyond technocratic approaches, governance reliability depends heavily on strengthening social capital. Mountain management models in countries with mature climbing traditions, such as Sweden with the principle of ‘Allemansrätten’ (the right to roam with full responsibility) or Japan through strict oversight systems by the Japan Alpine Club together with the government, demonstrate that collective awareness and community participation are key to sustainable management.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/managing-rimba-raya-commercialisation-and-governance-of-mountain-climbing-1787197924)
Originally published by Republika (https://retizen.republika.co.id/posts/777454/menata-rimba-raya-komersialisasi-dan-tata-kelola-pendakian-gunung), translated from Indonesian