Man Loses Testicle After Vasectomy and Wins Rp172bn in Compensation
Jakarta, CNBC Indonesia — A Pennsylvania man in the United States lost one of his testicles after undergoing a vasectomy in 2018. Eight years later, an appeals court ruled that he was entitled to about US$9.5 million, equivalent to Rp172 billion, in compensation from the urologist who performed the procedure.
According to the Times of India, the case involving Matthew Brennen began when he underwent a vasectomy in October 2018. The procedure is generally performed to prevent pregnancy by cutting or sealing the vas deferens, the tubes that carry sperm.
After the operation, however, Brennen experienced severe pain that grew worse. His condition made it difficult for him to move and prevented him from returning to work as expected.
On the third day after the operation, his wife, Lisa Brennen, contacted the doctor. They were then advised to take Matthew to hospital for further treatment.
Medical examinations showed that blood flow to Matthew’s left testicle had been impaired. He eventually underwent further surgery to have the testicle removed.
Alleged negligence during surgery
In a medical malpractice lawsuit, Matthew and his wife accused Dr Jason A. Smith and the urology practice Tri-County Urology Associates of negligence during the vasectomy. One of the main issues at trial was the failure to conduct a physical examination before surgery to establish the condition and position of the patient’s anatomical structures.
Medical experts’ testimony at the trial also raised concerns about the use of clips and sutures on structures in a way that allegedly disrupted blood flow to the testicle. According to an expert witness for the plaintiffs, these actions contributed to the damage to Matthew’s testicle.
In addition to losing the testicle, Matthew was reported to have suffered prolonged pain and numbness in the groin area. The effects also affected his daily activities and quality of life.
Appeals court upholds verdict
At the original trial, a jury in Fayette County found in favour of Matthew and Lisa Brennen, awarding total damages of about US$9.5 million.
Dr Smith and Tri-County Urology Associates subsequently appealed, challenging several aspects of the trial, including the sufficiency of the evidence and the basis for the award.
On 26 October 2026, however, the Pennsylvania Superior Court upheld the verdict. The panel found that the evidence presented at trial was sufficient to support the jury’s decision.
The ruling serves as an important reminder of medical practitioners’ responsibility to ensure that procedures meet applicable standards of care. Pre-operative examinations, accurate identification of anatomical structures and deciding to stop a procedure when conditions cannot be confirmed are all important in reducing the risk of serious complications.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/man-loses-testicle-after-vasectomy-and-wins-rp172bn-in-compensation-1793155829)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/lifestyle/20261028064721-33-780038/pria-kehilangan-testis-usai-vasektomi-dapat-ganti-rugi-rp172-m), translated from Indonesian