Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Mahfud MD on Constitutional Court Ruling Regarding Gibran: Implies Absence of Diploma

| Source: CNN Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Mahfud MD on Constitutional Court Ruling Regarding Gibran: Implies Absence of Diploma
Image: CNN Indonesia

Former Coordinating Minister for Political, Legal, and Security Affairs, as well as constitutional law expert, Mahfud MD, believes that the Constitutional Court’s ruling will pose a problem for Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka should he seek re-election in the 2029 General Election.

“This means there is no diploma, but the Constitutional Court did not dare to rule on this because there was no legal standing and no time. Therefore, it will become an issue for Gibran’s candidacy in 2029,” Mahfud stated in a video uploaded to his YouTube channel, @MahfudMD, on Wednesday (7/10).

In the video, Mahfud provided several observations regarding the Constitutional Court’s decision in case 01/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026 concerning the Dispute of the Results of the 2024 Presidential and Vice-Presidential General Election. Mahfud maintains that the Court acted within its authority, despite ongoing debates.

“In the Constitutional Court, for example, people have high expectations. There is debate on both sides. But, as I have said, the Court was indeed not authorised,” he remarked. “We respect the judges’ decision. The judges were brave enough to take a stance, and from a constitutional logic perspective, it is correct.”

He also addressed the issue of legal standing. Mahfud noted that since he no longer holds the status of a vice-presidential candidate for the 2024 General Election, the same applies to Gibran, meaning the lawsuit lacked the necessary legal standing.

“The Constitutional Court found facts that there is no evidence of a diploma, but because the time has passed, right? Because the parties with legal standing have already disbanded. For instance, as a vice-presidential candidate, when was that? It was in the past. I am no longer a candidate, and Gibran is no longer a candidate; he is now the Vice President,” he explained.

Nevertheless, Mahfud suggested that judges could have acted more boldly by issuing a declaratory judgement. He noted that such a declaratory ruling might already be hidden within the Court’s recently announced decision.

“If the judges were brave, much more could have happened. I have said that if the judges were brave, a declaratory judgement could have been given. However, it appears the declaratory ruling is already there. It is hidden,” Mahfud revealed.

He added that the issuance of this ruling does not mean the issue regarding Gibran’s diploma is resolved. Investigations could proceed through administrative law or employee disciplinary law, affecting not only Gibran but also the General Elections Commission (KPU).

“If desired, administrative law or employee disciplinary law could arise for those involved. For the KPU, it could be considered that they intentionally falsified something based on the proceedings in the Constitutional Court,” Mahfud stated.

Since the investigation involves criminal law, he noted that the police would be the primary authority responsible for handling it.

“However, once it involves other legal matters outside of this, the police will be the first to handle it. The police will be the ones to determine all of that,” he concluded.

The Constitutional Court read its decision regarding the lawsuit filed by Denny Indrayana et al. concerning Gibran’s High School (SMA) diploma or equivalent on Tuesday (6/10) night. One of the facts revealed in the ruling was that the Court found no documents proving Gibran possesses a diploma as evidence of completing overseas education equivalent to high school.

Despite this, the Court stated it could not disqualify Gibran from the office of Vice President. The Court has deferred any follow-up regarding the lack of evidence for the high school equivalent diploma to other institutions with the appropriate authority as regulated under the 1945 Constitution.

More from 7 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/mahfud-md-on-constitutional-court-ruling-regarding-gibran-implies-absence-of-diploma-1791360009)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261007132754-32-1412625/mahfud-md-soal-putusan-mk-terkait-gibran-berarti-tidak-ada-ijazah), translated from Indonesian
Print