Mahfud MD Launches Book Highlighting Current Political and Legal Landscape
A book that was once banned under certain regimes can become a bestseller under another. This is the journey of the book ‘Legal Politics in Indonesia’ by Professor Mahfud MD.
During the New Order era, the manuscript, derived from Mahfud MD’s dissertation, wandered from one publisher to another, rejected by all. The reason was uniform: no one had the courage to print it.
However, that once-avoided book has become a ‘mandatory text’ for law and politics students in this country over the last nearly three decades following the Reformation. The book has now reached its 13th printing and was re-launched at the University Club (UC) of Gadjah Mada University (UGM), Sleman, on Thursday (25/6).
This re-launch is not merely a change in cover design. In this latest edition, Mahfud also dissects the portrait of Indonesian law and politics throughout the 28-year journey of the Reformation era (1998–2026).
Mahfud stated that the 13th edition is not just a reprint, but a substantive revision that updates the book’s entire analysis with the developments in Indonesian politics and law during the 28 years of the Reformation era (199andum 2026).
“This book tells how our law has been heavily determined by politics,” he said.
Mahfud noted that Indonesian politics is not always detrimental to the law. Democratic politics will produce good legal products. He cited the 1950s as an era when Indonesia was very democratic; at that time, several ministers could be arrested without President Sukarno interfering.
He also noted that from the 1998 Reformation until 2009, according to Mahfud, good political conditions produced good legal products. In his historical notes, the early Reformation era (1998 to 2009) was a golden momentum for law enforcement in Indonesia. During that period, there were constitutional amendments, accelerated elections, the removal of non-elected representatives (such as the TNI faction) in the DPR, and the formation of the Constitutional Court (MK) and massive anti-corruption institutions.
“That [the Reformation] until 2009 was good. But starting from 2009, money politics began to emerge slowly. The current system for electing DPR members, based on the highest vote count, allows people to buy votes. It began at that time,” he concluded.
However, the situation has gradually changed since 2009. The emergence of the dominance of money politics due to the change in the highest-vote system is considered the starting point of this decline. This condition is assessed to have worsened from 2014 to the present.
“The current tendency is a decline, moving towards what is called ‘orthodox law’—law used for the agility or practical political interests of officials,” he asserted.
While not always having a negative impact, current law enforcement trends show indications of a concerning decline in quality.
According to him, the key to fixing the law in Indonesia is to improve the political system to be more democratic and representative, as well as to strengthen the country’s institutions.
Furthermore, he reminded public officials and state administrators to maintain their conduct for the sake of justice. History proves that power that ignores the law can collapse suddenly when the situation exceeds the public’s tolerance, as happened at the end of the Old Order and New Order eras.
Mahfud acknowledged that the government might have different views or a sense of security. However, he emphasised that as a scientist, he examines objectively based on the analysis of facts occurring in the field.
In closing, Mahfud provided a profound analogy regarding the relationship between law and politics in Indonesia that must be maintained together.
“Our country is a state based on law. Ideally, law and the constitution are the tracks, while politics is the locomotive and the carriages. Therefore, the locomotive and its driver must not violate the tracks, because if they go off course, the consequences are fatal and a collision will occur,” he concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/mahfud-md-launches-book-highlighting-current-political-and-legal-landscape-1782474623)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/904701/mahfud-md-luncurkan-buku-soroti-politik-hukum-terkini), translated from Indonesian