Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Macron Showcases the M51.3 as Putin Has the Sarmat: Which Nuclear Missile Is More Powerful?

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Politics

JAKARTA — French President Emmanuel Macron demonstrated his country’s nuclear deterrent with the launch of an M51.3 strategic ballistic missile from the nuclear-powered submarine Le Vigilant on Tuesday (6 October 2026). Designed to carry several nuclear warheads, the missile was fired over the Atlantic as tensions between Russia and European countries continued to rise. The demonstration was swiftly criticised by the Kremlin, which said Paris was increasingly orienting its defence strategy towards confrontation with Moscow.

Russian President Vladimir Putin, however, has a strategic weapon of considerably greater size and payload capacity: the RS-28 Sarmat, a land-based intercontinental ballistic missile that Putin has described as the world’s most powerful missile system. Moscow says the Sarmat can penetrate modern missile-defence systems and reach targets around the world.

The two missiles illustrate fundamental differences between France’s and Russia’s strategic weapons programmes. The M51.3 relies on covert launch capability from submarines, while the Sarmat is designed to carry a large strategic payload from land-based launch facilities. Comparing them involves not only range and the number of warheads, but also survivability and operational readiness.

According to Reuters, Macron watched the M51.3 launch from the frigate Auvergne off the coast of Brittany in western France. The test was conducted without a nuclear warhead and was intended to verify the readiness of the Le Vigilant submarine’s weapons system following a major overhaul. France’s Ministry of the Armed Forces said the launch went according to plan and complied with international obligations.

“Today we are stronger. The message has been delivered clearly to those who need to receive it,” Macron said in a statement quoted by Reuters on Tuesday (6 October 2026).

Macron did not identify Russia directly as the intended recipient. However, the test took place amid growing debate over European security, the war in Ukraine and Russia’s warnings that it could use nuclear force if its territory came under attack. Macron’s presence at the test gave a political dimension to a military activity that had been planned in advance.

The Kremlin responded the following day. Russian presidential spokesperson Dmitry Peskov said Moscow had received France’s message, but criticised the tendency among European countries to build their defence policies around confrontation with Russia.

“This is a dead end. As history has shown, this approach leads to nothing good,” Peskov said, according to Reuters on Wednesday (7 October 2026).

Peskov also said Russia remained alert to military developments in Europe but was open to dialogue on regional security. In his view, security issues should be resolved through negotiations rather than missile-launch demonstrations.

M51.3: Nuclear power from beneath the sea

The M51.3 is the third generation of France’s M51 strategic ballistic missile family, developed for the country’s nuclear-powered submarine weapons system. It is a submarine-launched ballistic missile (SLBM) and a key component of France’s sea-based nuclear deterrent.

France’s Ministry of the Armed Forces said the M51.3 entered operational service on 24 October 2025. Developed by ArianeGroup, the missile has improved range, accuracy and ability to penetrate missile defences compared with earlier versions. It is also designed to carry the new-generation TNO-2 nuclear warhead.

According to the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), the M51 family is about 13 metres long, 2.35 metres in diameter and has a launch weight of approximately 53 tonnes. The missile uses three solid-fuel booster stages and is designed to carry several warheads aimed at different targets. This technology is known as multiple independently targetable re-entry vehicles (MIRVs).

CSIS estimates that the M51 family can carry around four to six warheads. However, this figure refers to the missile family in general and cannot be confirmed as the specific operational configuration of the M51.3. The French government has not disclosed full details of the payload of its latest strategic missile.

Paris has not publicly announced the M51.3’s maximum range. Reuters reported on 6 October 2026 that public estimates for the M51 family generally put its range at around 9,000 kilometres or more, while French officials have said the latest version has greater range. This figure is an estimate of the system’s capability, not a maximum distance measured in the latest test and announced by the government.

However, the M51.3’s strength is not determined solely by its ability to reach distant targets. The missile is deployed on submarines that can operate covertly at sea, making the launch platform’s location difficult for a potential adversary to identify. Keeping a submarine’s location secret is central to deterrence because it helps preserve the ability to retaliate.

France operates four Le Triomphant-class nuclear-powered ballistic missile submarines. They form the backbone of the sea-based nuclear force Paris maintains to protect the country’s vital interests. The M51.3 is intended to sustain the credibility of that capability as other countries develop increasingly sophisticated missile-defence systems.

Sarmat: Putin’s giant missile

Unlike the submarine-launched M51.3, the RS-28 Sarmat is a silo-based land-launched intercontinental ballistic missile (ICBM). Russia developed it to replace the Soviet-era R-36M2 Voevoda system, which had been in service for several decades. The Sarmat is one of Russia’s strategic nuclear-force modernisation projects, announced by Putin in 2018.

The difference in size between the two missiles is striking. According to CSIS Missile Threat data, the Sarmat is about 35.3 metres long, three metres in diameter and has a launch weight of approximately 208 tonnes. It uses three liquid-fuel booster stages and is designed to carry a strategic payload of up to around 10 tonnes.

More from 8 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/macron-showcases-the-m51-3-as-putin-has-the-sarmat-which-nuclear-missile-is-more-powerful-1791450047)
Originally published by Republika (https://news.republika.co.id/berita/tmkvf0451/macron-pamer-m513-putin-punya-sarmat-rudal-nuklir-siapa-lebih-unggul), translated from Indonesian
Print