Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

MA Corrects State Loss in Tin Corruption Case from Rp300 T to Rp28 T

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
MA Corrects State Loss in Tin Corruption Case from Rp300 T to Rp28 T
Image: CNBC Indonesia

The Supreme Court (MA) has corrected the calculation of state losses in the tin trading corruption case involving former Director of Production Operations of PT Timah Tbk, Alwin Albar. The MA affirmed that the figure of up to Rp300 trillion calculated so far does not fully fall within the category of state financial losses from the perspective of corruption.

The state loss after revision has been reduced from Rp300 trillion to Rp28 trillion.

The cassation panel of judges for this case, led by Prim Haryadi, stated that the figure was calculated by separating corruption losses from the impact of environmental damage. This is set out in Decision Number 11179 K/Pid.Sus/2025.

“The total loss consists of excess payments made without adequate feasibility studies amounting to Rp28 trillion, while the remaining losses are environmental losses comprising ecological losses, environmental economic losses, and restoration costs valued at Rp271 trillion,” the panel stated in its ruling, as quoted from an official statement on Wednesday (12/8/2026).

The MA assessed that the calculation of state losses should only be based on the outflow of state funds that occurred unlawfully or the loss of state profits that can be calculated with certainty. Environmental damage, on the other hand, is considered to have a different character and legal regime and therefore cannot be mixed into the term corruption.

“Although environmental losses, whether due to environmental damage or ecological damage, can be calculated and assessed by experts, including restoration costs, such environmental damage does not automatically become part of state financial losses,” the ruling continued.

In its official decision document, the panel detailed the results of the audit by the Financial and Development Supervisory Agency (BPKP) used in the previous trial. The judges validated the loss value of Rp300 trillion resulting from procedural irregularities in the cooperation for leasing smelting equipment and payments for tin ore without feasibility studies.

“That the total loss of Rp300,003,263,938,131.14 consists of excess payments (overpricing) for the Cooperation for Leasing of Processing and Smelting Equipment between PT Timah Tbk and private smelters and the value of payments for tin ore to mining partners of PT Timah Tbk, which were made without adequate feasibility studies, totalling Rp28,933,575,919,431.14,” the decision document stated.

The panel also considered that the separation aims to optimise law enforcement in each respective sector. In this way, the restoration of the environment damaged by mining activities is expected to be carried out more effectively and with better targeting.

“Declaring environmental damage to be included in state financial losses in the a quo case is inappropriate, because the environmental damage valued at Rp271,069,688,018,700.00 should constitute a separate offence and be prosecuted separately under the environmental law regime, so that restoration of the damaged environment can be carried out promptly,” the document stated.

The decision also refers to Supreme Court Circular Letter (SEMA) Number 2 of 2024 concerning the authority of state institutions in determining state losses.

Although it corrected the loss value, the Supreme Court still rejected the cassation appeals filed by the defendant and the public prosecutor, while making improvements to the previous court decision.

More from 12 August 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/ma-corrects-state-loss-in-tin-corruption-case-from-rp300-t-to-rp28-t-1786510309)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20260812103228-4-758513/bukan-rp300-t-ma-koreksi-kerugian-negara-di-korupsi-timah-jadi-rp28-t), translated from Indonesian
Print