Luhut Proposes That State Losses Should Not Constitute Corruption; KPK Deputy Chairman Disagrees
KPK Deputy Chairman Johanis Tanak disagrees with the proposal by National Economic Council (DEN) Chairman Luhut Pandjaitan that state losses should not be classified as corruption. Tanak also explained why he opposes the idea.
“I disagree with Mr Luhut’s thinking and proposal,” Tanak told reporters on Wednesday (21 October 2026).
He said that if state financial losses were removed from Indonesia’s corruption offences, the state would have no basis to prosecute people whose actions caused losses to public finances. In his view, state losses in corruption cases generally result from state officials acting together with private-sector parties.
“Bribery and extortion in corruption cases are generally connected to government procurement projects, which are funded by state finances or foreign loans,” Tanak said.
“Bribery between the contracting party and the contractor in government procurement generally means that the work delivered does not meet the specified requirements, causing losses to the state,” he continued.
Tanak said there were many examples of corruption cases that had caused losses to state finances. He cited a case involving the National Search and Rescue Agency (Basarnas), in which state funds were used for the personal benefit of individuals or others, or for a corporation.
Regarding the United Nations Convention against Corruption (UNCAC), Tanak said it was a comprehensive international legal instrument covering five main pillars of corruption prevention and eradication.
These are prevention measures; criminalisation and law enforcement; international cooperation; asset recovery; and technical assistance and information exchange.
He said UNCAC, which Indonesia ratified through Law No. 7 of 2006, neither prohibits nor limits provisions in the anti-corruption laws of UN member states. Tanak added that conduct causing losses to state finances or the national economy could be classified under UNCAC’s criminalisation and law enforcement framework.
“Even if the issue relates to the activities of state-owned companies, it could be regulated under the State-Owned Enterprises Law so that their business activities are not classified as corruption,” Tanak said.
“The Limited Liability Companies Law also provides legal protection for company directors under Article 97(5) of Law No. 40 of 2007 on Limited Liability Companies. It remains in force and has undergone substantial amendments through Law No. 6 of 2023, which enacted Government Regulation in Lieu of Law No. 2 of 2022 on Job Creation,” he added.
Tanak said that if the government wanted state-owned companies’ assets not to be classified as state finances, it could amend the State-Owned Enterprises Law. He argued there was no need to amend the anti-corruption law by removing its definitions of losses to state finances or the national economy.
“That is why I disagree with Mr Luhut’s proposal,” he concluded.
Luhut had earlier proposed a review of Indonesia’s definition of corruption, raising the idea directly with President Prabowo Subianto.
“The President also agreed with the study prepared by the National Economic Council team on the definition of corruption,” Luhut said at the Merdeka Palace in Central Jakarta on Tuesday (20 October).
His proposal is that state losses should not constitute corruption. He said this would be consistent with the UNCAC, which the government has ratified.
“We refer to the UN Convention’s chapter on the definition of corruption. The definition in the UN Convention ratified by the government 20 years ago concerns bribery; it does not discuss state losses,” Luhut said.
Luhut said Indonesia was the only country to treat state losses as one form of corruption. In his view, this placed a burden on the business operations of state-owned companies, including Danantara’s ability to undertake corporate actions.
“Indonesia is the only country that applies the issue of state losses. This makes things difficult for businesses such as Danantara, because every business activity carries risks. I think this is important,” Luhut said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/luhut-proposes-that-state-losses-should-not-constitute-corruption-kpk-deputy-chairman-disagrees-1792594500)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8718058/luhut-usul-kerugian-negara-bukan-pidana-korupsi-wakil-ketua-kpk-tak-setuju), translated from Indonesian