Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Looking Back to 7 October 2023: Why Did Israel Fail to Understand Hamas?

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Politics
Looking Back to 7 October 2023: Why Did Israel Fail to Understand Hamas?
Image: Republika

GAZA — The failure of Israeli intelligence agencies to predict the Al-Aqsa Flood operation has prompted a reassessment of how they study Hamas and understand the direction of its policies.

An evaluation conducted after the attack found weaknesses in assessing the influence of religious thought on Hamas’s decisions.

The Jerusalem Post reported on 11 October 2026, citing Al Jazeera on Friday (6 November 2026), that Israel’s General Security Service (Shin Bet, or Shabak) plans to establish a dedicated school for Islamic studies. The initiative was proposed by Shabak chief David Zini.

The school will operate alongside Shabak’s Arabic-language education institute. Its teaching programme will involve academics, experts and serving and retired security officials.

The curriculum will cover Islam, its various currents and schools of thought, and different interpretations, with an emphasis on themes related to the security challenges facing the agency.

The initiative follows an internal Israeli review which concluded that the country’s intelligence agencies had not adequately understood Hamas’s ideology.

They were also judged to have failed to interpret how the movement evolved after Yahya Sinwar’s release in 2011, and to have overlooked the continuing influence of Hamas founder Sheikh Ahmed Yassin’s thinking on the movement’s strategy.

Although Israel had intelligence about Hamas’s preparations ahead of the Al-Aqsa Flood operation, its reliance on signals intelligence and cyber capabilities — which enable the interception of telephone calls, messages and other communications — sidelined specialist expertise in Islamic thought and Palestinian culture. As a result, Hamas’s behaviour was interpreted through assumptions that failed to grasp or anticipate the movement’s motives and objectives.

The Israeli review concluded that its intelligence agencies had not adequately understood Hamas’s ideology.

The plan to establish an Islamic studies school comes as several Israeli studies examining the role of religious ideology in Hamas’s decision-making have been published.

Those studies question whether Israeli security agencies overstated the influence of economic interests and the responsibilities of governing on Hamas’s behaviour, while underestimating a crucial factor: the movement’s religious perspective on the conflict.

More from 6 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/looking-back-to-7-october-2023-why-did-israel-fail-to-understand-hamas-1793962283)
Originally published by Republika (https://news.republika.co.id/berita/to2sl7320/berangkat-dari-7-oktober-2023-mengapa-israel-gagal-pahami-hamas), translated from Indonesian
Print