Local Bureaucracy: Between Servants of the State and Administrators of the People
Bureaucratic reform in the regions is once again being questioned. On paper, its design appears neat: digitalisation, meritocracy, efficiency, and performance orientation. However, in practice, the reality is often the opposite—performance is not yet optimal, work culture is rigid, and policies frequently change according to the whims of leaders. The problem is not merely technical. It touches on deeper roots: the power relations between politics and bureaucracy, which have never truly been resolved since ancient times. We are witnessing a worrying phenomenon: the return of bureaucracy as pangreh praja, not pamong praja. Civil servants are no longer fully public servants, but potentially instruments of power. One of the most vulnerable points lies in leadership discontinuity. Every change of regional head is almost always followed by policy changes, even the dismantling of the bureaucracy. Running programmes can be halted, competent officials shifted, and development directions changed without adequate evaluation. The excuse is simple: different visions and missions. However, behind that, more problematic practices are often hidden—bureaucratic arrangements laden with political interests. Furthermore, the merit system that has long been touted has not fully worked. Promotions and job mutations are still often coloured by non-performance factors: closeness, political loyalty, even transactions. The phenomenon of “buying and selling positions” that repeatedly surfaces is not merely an individual deviation. It is a systemic symptom of the high cost of regional elections. Elected regional heads often carry the burden of political favours, which are then translated into bureaucratic position placements. As a result, professional civil servants are sidelined, while opportunists gain space. In the long term, this creates collective demoralisation within the bureaucracy. On the other hand, digitalisation, which is expected to be a solution, instead presents a new paradox. Stacked applications, unintegrated systems, and weak coordination between regional work units persist. Instead of accelerating services, digitalisation often turns into an additional administrative burden. We are like building a “digital bureaucracy” without changing the logic of the bureaucracy itself. The supervisory function, which should serve as a balance, also has not worked optimally. Regional people’s representative councils have strong mandates—legislation, budgeting, and oversight—but in practice, their effectiveness is often weak.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/local-bureaucracy-between-servants-of-the-state-and-administrators-of-the-people-1776408656)
Originally published by Kompas (https://nasional.kompas.com/read/2026/04/17/13220531/birokrasi-daerah-antara-pangreh-dan-pamong?utm_source=ABC&utm_medium=rss), translated from Indonesian