List of Regional Heads at Odds Amid Discourse on Deputy-Free Elections
Disputes between regional heads and their deputies, even spilling into the public sphere, have triggered discourse on holding regional elections without deputies in Commission II of the House of Representatives (DPR).
Instead of sharing roles, the existence of deputy regional heads has also been criticised for merely serving as a spare tyre and a vote getter.
Several members of Commission II from various factions have proposed that deputy regional heads should simply be appointed by the elected regional head. In fact, a regional head could have more than one deputy depending on workload or needs.
“Let us just elect regional heads without deputies. Deputy regional heads should be appointed by the regional head. This is so they do not just become vote getters; pity the current deputy regional heads,” said Commission II member from the PKB faction, Muhammad Khozin, during a meeting with the Home Affairs Minister on 30 July.
Khozin even claimed to possess data showing that 60 per cent of regional heads have a disharmonious relationship with their deputies.
“Nearly 60 per cent of the data we have in the regions shows disharmony between regional heads and deputy regional heads,” he said.
CNNIndonesia.com has compiled a number of cases of disputes and the hot-and-cold relationships between regional heads and their deputies. The disputes are triggered by several factors, especially an unbalanced division of duties.
Regent and Deputy Regent of Sidoarjo
Tension between Sidoarjo Regent Subandi and his deputy Mimik Idayana sharpened after a large-scale reshuffle of civil servants in their region in September 2025.
Mimik protested Subandi’s decision to carry out the reshuffle without involving her. She considered the reshuffle decision to be non-compliant with procedure and threatened to report it to the Ministry of Home Affairs.
The report was officially lodged on 29 September 2025 via letter number 000.6.3.4/11268/438.1/2025.
Mayor and Deputy Mayor of Bandung
Deputy Mayor of Bandung Erwin complained that he was insufficiently involved by Mayor Muhammad Farhan in government work.
In a statement to the media on 6 July 2026, Erwin admitted he had never been invited to participate in strategic city government programmes, ranging from budgeting, work programmes, to reshuffles.
“Frankly, all this time I have never been invited by the mayor or involved in programmes in the city of Bandung. This has actually been happening since the inauguration,” said Erwin.
Farhan denied Erwin’s statement. He said Erwin was still invited to a number of agendas, and assured that his relationship with Erwin was harmonious. He acknowledged that the deputy mayor does not have many duties, because this has been regulated by the Ministry of Home Affairs.
“Based on the Home Affairs Ministerial Regulation, the duties of a deputy regional head are only those assigned by the regional head. So far, the tasks given are indeed not as many as before, because some have already been running on their own,” he said.
Regent and Deputy Regent of Lebak
Lebak Regent Hasbi Jayabaya and his deputy Amir Hamzah openly clashed during an Idulfitri 1447 H halal bihalal gathering with civil servants at the Lebak Regency Pendopo in Banten on Monday morning (30/3).
At the time, Amir was angered because Hasbi brought up a past corruption case that had ensnared him.
In his speech, Hasbi insinuated that Amir was fortunate to be able to serve as Deputy Regent of Lebak, especially given Amir’s status as a former convict.
Amir Hamzah is known to have been ensnared by the Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) in a bribery case related to the 2013 Lebak Regency regional election dispute, alongside Tb Chaeri Wardana alias TCW and former Constitutional Court Chief Justice Akil Mochtar. In that case, he was sentenced to 3 years and 5 months in prison by a panel of judges on 21 December 2015.
Later, Hasbi visited Amir on 1 April. The two were seen shaking hands. Hasbi explained his reason for visiting the deputy regent’s home.
“I also dared to come to the Deputy’s house because I feel that besides being deputy regent, he is also a senior, an elder,” Hasbi told journalists.
Regent and Deputy Regent of Jember
Deputy Regent of Jember Djoko Santoso reported Regent Muhammad Fawait to the KPK in September 2025.
The report was lodged by Djoko because he felt he had never been involved in any strategic programmes or important decision-making. Through a letter dated 4 September, Djoko claimed he had never been involved during his six months in office.
The conflict then continued when Djoko sued Fawait at the Jember District Court over the alleged withdrawal of rights and facilities in February 2026. However, through his legal counsel, Fawait denied the allegations.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/list-of-regional-heads-at-odds-amid-discourse-on-deputy-free-elections-1786409623)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260810195445-32-1390766/daftar-kepala-daerah-pecah-kongsi-di-tengah-isu-pilkada-tanpa-wakil), translated from Indonesian