Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Lighter Sentences for Two Soldiers in Andrie Yunus Acid Attack Case Draw Criticism

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Lighter Sentences for Two Soldiers in Andrie Yunus Acid Attack Case Draw Criticism
Image: detikcom

The appeal verdict from the Jakarta Military High Court regarding the defendants responsible for the acid attack on KontraS activist Andrie Yunus has drawn widespread criticism. The ruling reduced prison sentences and overturned the additional penalty of dismissal from military service for two TNI (Indonesian National Armed Forces) members.

This was stated in the verdict of appeal Number 56-K/PMT-II/BDG/AL/VI/2026, as reported by the Military Court Case Tracking Information System (SIPP) on Saturday (5/9/2026).

Prison Sentences Reduced and Dismissal Overturned

The panel of judges at the Military High Court II-08 Jakarta reduced the sentences of two TNI members who acted as the executors of the acid attack against Andrie Yunus. The Military Court judges also overturned the dismissal from military service for both individuals.

The two defendants are Sergeant Edi Sudarko and Lieutenant Budhi Hariyanto Wiidhi Cahyono.

“Amending the Decision of the Military Court II-08 Jakarta Number 7lan 70-K/PM II-08/AL/IV/2026 dated 10 June 2026, regarding Defendant-1 and Defendant-2 only in terms of their criminal punishment,” read the verdict.

In this appeal, the prison terms for Edi and Budhi were reduced. Edi’s previous sentence of 3 years was reduced to 2 years and 6 months, while Budhi’s previous sentence of 2 years and 6 months was reduced to 2 years.

Meanwhile, the sentences for defendants Captain Nandala Dwi Prasetya and Lieutenant Sami Lakka remained unchanged. Nandala remains sentenced to 2 years in prison, and Sami remains sentenced to 1 year and 6 months.

First Instance Court Decision

At the first instance trial, the judges found the defendants guilty of violating Article 467, paragraph 1 in conjunction with paragraph 2 and Article 20 letter c of Law Number 1 of 2023 regarding the Criminal Code (KUHP). The judge stated that Defendant I, Edi, had provoked the other defendants.

The judge identified Defendant II, Budhi, as the party who initiated the acid attack on Andrie. Budhi was also identified as the person who prepared the acid mixture.

Furthermore, the judge noted that Defendant III, Nandala, was an officer who should have prevented the incident but instead participated in planning the act. The judge added that Nandlam and Sami also assisted in locating Andrie Yunus.

The defendants’ actions caused Andrie Yunus to suffer disabilities, including the loss of his ability to read. According to the judge, the 2.5-year prison demand was not proportionate to Defendant I’s actions, but was appropriate for Defendant II. Conversely, the judge deemed the 2.5-year prison demand for Defendants III and IV to be too heavy.

Edi and Budhi Ordered Dismissed

The judge also imposed the additional penalty of dismissal from military service for defendants Edi and Budhi. The judge held personal considerations for this dismissal, even though it was not included in the prosecutor’s demand.

“Defendants I and II are no longer worthy of being maintained in the TNI service,” the judge stated while reading the considerations for the additional penalty of dismissal.

Aggravating factors in the ruling included the defendants’ status as TNI soldiers who betrayed their duty by carrying out the acid attack on Andrie Yunus. The act was deemed to have damaged the image of the TNI, was carried out intentionally, demonstrated arrogance, caused trauma and suffering, and resulted in permanent eye damage for Andrie Yunus.

Mitigating factors included the defendants’ admission of guilt, their lack of prior criminal records, the professional achievements of Defendants I, II, and III, and their intention to apologise to the Commander of the TNI, the Minister of Defence, and the victim.

Criticism from TAUD

The Advocacy Team for Democracy (TAUD) expressed disappointment over the verdict, where the sentences of two TNI soldiers were reduced and their dismissal from military service was overturned. TAUD believes the ruling failed to consider the losses suffered by Andrie.

“The decision of the Military Court II Jakarta did not consider the losses experienced by the victim, including damage to his eyesight and approximately 20 percent skin burns. The verdict further demonstrates the importance of military court reform to align with modern criminal law developments, principles of victim protection, and standards of fair justice,” TAFT wrote in a press release on the KontraS website, Saturday (5/9).

“Upon reading the verdict, the wording appears strange and unusual because, on one hand, the appeal verdict changes the primary punishment, but on the other hand, it does not provide clarity on whether the additional penalty of dismissal from military service, which was imposed at the first instance, was also changed or remains in effect. This ambiguity naturally creates the impression that the dismissal of defendants Edi Sudarko and Budhi Hariyanto Widhi has been annulled,” it continued.

TAUD is a coalition comprising the Indonesian Legal Aid Foundation (YLBHI), LBH Jakarta, AMAR Law Firm & Public Interest Law Office, KontraS, LBH Pers, Trend Asia, Imparsial, and Greenpeace Indonesia.

TAUD views the Military High Court’s decision as favouring the defendants and ignoring relevant evidence. According to TAUD, this not only has the potential to damage the dignity of the judiciary but also erodes the principles of a state based on the rule of law.

“The alteration of the verdict of the Military Court II-08 Jakarta by the Military High Court II Jakarta actually shows a construction of criminal punishment that is more favourable to the Defendants, while the trial process was held behind closed doors and potentially ignored or selectively used relevant evidence and facts. This condition prevents the process of seeking material truth from being complete,” they stated.

More from 6 September 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/lighter-sentences-for-two-soldiers-in-andrie-yunus-acid-attack-case-draw-criticism-1788663344)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8650457/vonis-terbaru-2-tentara-kasus-andrie-yunus-lebih-ringan-tuai-kritikan), translated from Indonesian
Print