Liberty often abused by RI powerholders
Liberty often abused by RI powerholders
By Ignas Kleden
This is the second of two articles on liberty in Indonesia
since it shed the colonial yoke in 1945.
JAKARTA (JP): The flourishing of institutional and mental
corruption will make it impossible for former president Soeharto
to deny whatsoever that the political system under his leadership
was a corrupt one.
Under his administration, the rule of law did not work,
political decision-making was never transparent, the workings of
bureaucracy were not accountable and the power of the president
was beyond any possible legal and political control.
The question is: From where did the institutional and mental
corruption of the system come? Can we assume that institutional
and mental corruption were able to exist and develop without an
underlying money corruption?
Considering the pronounced paternalistic pattern of most of
Indonesian cultures, it is very difficult to assume that the
practices of corruption developed despite the leaders's being
politically "immaculate". Supposing that the leadership was clean
at that time, how is it to explain that it was totally unable to
control and stop those bad practices? In that sense, the
accountability of the former president should not only be limited
to a probe into his personal wealth but should also include an
account of bad political behavior and decadent political culture
during the New Order era.
The advent of the reform movement launched by courageous young
students was, therefore, welcomed enthusiastically by the whole
Indonesian society. Enough is enough -- a dignified nation and a
free country cannot sustain its life on such shaky ground without
any principle underlying it except naked power.
The advent of the reform movement was a sort of a new freedom
for the country from the bondage of the New Order
administration's triple sins: corruption, collusion and nepotism.
The reform movement was, and still is, a redemptive action
that salvaged the country from total collapse. The demand for
total reform is, therefore, only logical. The question is: How
long will this new freedom last? Will it take five or 10 years
for the country and its people to fall back again into another
sort of bondage, which will be justified by the same reasons
which are now shepherding in freedom? This is a political
question which should be solved with political decisions and
actions.
The answer depends very much on how Indonesians view and treat
the power they delegate to their representatives and to the
government. They should keep in mind that political power is a
delegated power. It is the people who provide the government with
power and the government is, therefore, obliged to be accountable
for what purposes and in which manner the power is exercised and
used. There are, at least, three related reasons why social
control of power is necessarily required.
* If the people are the source of power and if the government
is nothing but the executor of the power delegated by the people,
it is the people who are entitled to control the exercising of
power and not the government.
* The tendency of power to corrupt is proportional to the size
of power one has at one's disposal. People with little power can
only commit little mistakes and people with great power are
always liable to the greatest possible wrongdoings.
* The powerholder has vast capacity: ruling the people, waging
the war, issuing regulations and controlling the economy and
business. However, he or she will always lack one essential
capacity -- the ability to control his or her power.
The built-in control introduced by Sudharmono when he was vice
president was a good initiative, but it had a very limited
effect. The reason was that the built-in control system was only
able to exercise administrative control but never political
control. Besides that, such a control was exercised within a
closed administrative system and never had the power of a public
and social control.
The advent of the reform movement was again another moment of
regaining the same liberty from the closeness of the New Order
government. People were partly enthusiastic and partly
disillusioned that the power of the New Order administration was
terminated much sooner than expected. It was even too soon to
enable many groups to make preparations for the post-Soeharto
era.
One is quickly reminded of the controversy between Sukarno and
his political opponents regarding the right time for national
independence: first freedom and then get prepared, or first
preparation and then get free. Both might be right, depending on
how serious the preparation is done.
A big lesson Indonesians have learned from the transition from
one political order to another is that in fact, the nation, the
people and the country are always determined to attain freedom
and liberty but they are not equally good and prepared to make
that freedom and liberty sustainable in their political life. The
freedom has always turned out to be easily truncated,
domesticated or paralyzed by the powerholder, which is not so
difficult to understand. The liberty of people is proportional to
the extent that power is controlled or becomes arbitrary. The
less freedom, the more arbitrary the power and vice versa.
The second lesson is that the threat for national freedom does
not only come from outside. It can just as well originate from
within. It seems that power tends to have the same behavior
whether it is exercised by a foreign ruler or a domestic one. In
the first case, a foreign powerholder contradicts the right of
self-determination because the power is just exerted upon the
people without their agreement to delegate it to the said
powerholder. In the latter case, the powerholder can contradict
the same principle, in that he denies practically (albeit not
verbally) that the power he is exercising is delegated by the
people and is, therefore, subject to their control.
It seems that what should be maintained and defended is not
only freedom but also the struggle for freedom. In fact, there
will be never liberty from the struggle for liberty and there
will never be freedom from the requirement to stand up for
freedom.
The writer is a sociologist based in Jakarta.
Window: They should keep in mind that political power is a
delegated power. It is the people who provide the government with
power and the government is, therefore, obliged to be accountable
for what purposes and in which manner the power is exercised and
used.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/liberty-often-abused-by-ri-powerholders-1447893297-1404048)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post