Lessons from Ningxia: How China's Targeted Poverty Alleviation Can Inform Indonesia's 2026 Zero Extreme Poverty Goal
Social media platforms are believed to be able to prevent children from falsifying their age.
An honour. The Sino-Nusantara Institute, the only Indonesian think-tank focused on Indonesia-China issues, was invited by China’s central authority, the IDCPC, to an international seminar titled ‘China: From Theory and Practice in Poverty Alleviation’ on 8-9 July 2026 in Yinchuan, capital of the Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region. Alongside hundreds of participants from 35 countries, we observed and learned together how China succeeded in eliminating extreme poverty in 2020.
The main focus of China’s poverty alleviation programme targeted rural standards, ensuring adequate food, clothing, and access to basic education and health services. For infrastructure support, the government invested trillions of yuan to relocate residents from remote areas and to build roads and housing. According to China’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs, this contributed more than 70% to global poverty alleviation efforts.
China’s success in lifting more than 800 million people out of extreme poverty is recognised by the world and the United Nations. It is the greatest poverty alleviation achievement in human history. That is why the forum in Yinchuan matters. Not to imitate, but to learn the methods.
For the author, this was not a first visit to China. I have travelled in and out of China for more than 10 years. From Shanghai and Shenzhen in the east, to Gansu and Ningxia in the west. From skyscrapers to villages on the periphery that were once nothing but dirt and dust. Ten years ago, many villages in Ningxia and Gansu were still poor. Today there is village e-commerce, solar power plants in the desert, and decent housing. I visited Gansu and Ningxia directly, regions in western China known for their extreme natural conditions. During the golden era of the Silk Road hundreds of years ago, this region was one of the important routes from the west into China and vice versa.
From that experience and the forum in Yinchuan, there are important lessons for Indonesia, which targets 0% extreme poverty by 2026.
THE REAL CONDITION OF POVERTY IN INDONESIA
Based on Statistics Indonesia (BPS) data from September 2024, the number of poor people in Indonesia stands at 24.06 million, or 8.57%. Of that number, extreme poverty — those whose expenditure falls below Rp14,525 per capita per day — is recorded at 4.12 million people, or 1.47%. This is a significant decline from 2.06% in March 2024. However, the challenges remain great. Data from the Ministry of Social Affairs shows there are still 9.9 million beneficiary families of the Family Hope Programme (PKH) and 18.8 million recipients of non-cash food assistance (BPNT) who must be continuously protected so they do not fall back into poverty.
The government’s target is clear. In the 2025-2029 National Medium-Term Development Plan (RPJMN), President Prabowo targets 0% extreme poverty by 2026 and total poverty falling to 4.5%-5% by 2029. This is not an easy target. We need speed, precision, and sustainability.
THE STATE IS PRESENT, BUT DOES NOT STANDARDISE
China under Xi Jinping has the concept of ‘Socialism with Chinese Characteristics for a New Era’. Its essence: the state is present strongly, in a planned manner, and ‘no one is left behind’. Indonesia has Pancasila. The fifth principle, ‘Social Justice for All Indonesian People’, is the soul of PKH, BPNT, and the Free Nutritious Meals programme (MBG).
Over 10 years, I have seen the key is the same. The state must not be absent. But it also must not treat everyone identically. The instruments differ. The goal is the same. Our task is not to copy, but to absorb the methods, then adapt them through deliberation and mutual cooperation.
SPEED, REGIONAL CHARACTER, AND PILOT PROJECTS
In the 1970s China was extremely poor. GDP per capita was US$110. Reform began in 1978. The period 2013-2020 was the ‘final assault’: 98.99 million people exited poverty in eight years. This speed has been felt in the last five years. Toll roads cut through mountains. The internet reached villages. But that speed was not uniform. Western and eastern China differ. The east, like Shanghai and Zhejiang: industry, ports, exports. The west, like Gansu and Ningxia: arid, mountainous, disaster-prone, home to many ethnic minorities. Therefore, the policies differ.
In Gansu, the problem was barren land. The answer: massive ecological relocation, desert greening, irrigation, and solar and wind power plants in the desert. Hundreds of thousands of residents moved to new towns. Barren land became the largest power generation sites. In Ningxia, the challenge for the Hui people, known as China’s largest Muslim ethnic group, was a region with dry land. The answer: the halal industry, goji berry e-commerce, and water-efficient irrigation.
Then there is the Dongxibu Xiezuo policy — East-West Cooperation — running since 1996, now 30 years old. Rich provinces or major cities in the east ‘assist’ poor provinces or counties in the west. Tianjin helps Gansu. Fujian helps Ningxia, and so on. They send mentors, funds, teachers, and doctors, but tailored to local character.
One more thing: pilot projects. Every new policy is first tested in one or two counties. Evaluated. If successful, only then is it replicated nationally. Not rolled out directly to 1.4 billion people.
FIVE THINGS WE CAN ADAPT
First, precise data. Since 2013 China has had a national database. Every poor household has an ‘identity card’. The causes of poverty are recorded, what assistance is given, and who is responsible. Data is updated monthly. There is no blanket approach. Indonesia has started with Regsosek 2022 and DTKS. But real-time integration and monthly updates as in China still need to be pursued.
Second, the One Click System. After 2020, China created a safety net called the ‘One Click System’. If a family faces serious illness, redundancy, or crop failure, they simply ‘click’ to report. Within seven days a verification team arrives. If eligible, emergency assistance, medical aid, or training is disbursed immediately.
I saw this system in Gansu. Its purpose is clear: to prevent people ‘falling back into poverty’. To protect the results of eight years of work so they are not lost due to a single shock. Indonesia needs this to protect the 9.9 million PKH beneficiary families and 18.8 million BPNT recipients so they do not fall again when economic shocks occur.
Third, matching regional character. There is no single prescription. Gansu: new energy plus relocation plus desert tourism. Ningxia: halal industry plus precision agriculture plus e-commerce. Guizhou: data centres plus tourism. All decided through data and village deliberation. This is relevant for us. BPS data shows the highest poverty is in Papua (24.83%), East Nusa Tenggara (19.02%), and Maluku (15.92%). Clearly Papua differs from East Nusa Tenggara. East Nusa Tenggara differs from Kalimantan. Policy must be born from below.
Fourth, the role of society. China’s success is not the state alone. Millions of party cadres ‘went down to the villages’, living there for three to five years. But communities were also involved. There are Village Supervisory Councils. Some run e-commerce. In villages on the outskirts of Ningxia, women’s groups (PKK) become online shop administrators and work in local-based industries that bring together farmers, livestock breeders, and entrepreneurs. Products are sold in real time on online platforms and supplied to other regions within the east-west cooperation scheme. Without citizen involvement, however large a programme is, it will fail.
Fifth, sustainability and anti-corruption. This is the key. Poverty programmes in China have binding five- and ten-year roadmaps. They do not change even when leaders change. Consistent across periods.
There are three guarantors:
Binding targets. A regent who fails to meet targets is removed.
Digital oversight. All funds can be tracked in real time.
Firm sanctions. Corruption of poverty funds is punished severely. No compromise. That is why the results are sustainable.
MOVING TOGETHER: GOVERNMENT, SOCIETY, AND ACADEMIA
One of the most important lessons from China: ‘moving together’. There, poverty alleviation is not the work of a single ministry. Central government, provinces, counties, down to villages move under one command. No one works alone. They partner with communities, NGOs, community figures, and academia. Data and science form the foundation. Universities are tasked with research: which crops suit Gansu’s soil, which e-commerce model sells in Ningxia. Research results immediately become policy. Party cadres, NGOs, and community figures become the bridge. They supervise, distribute, and educate citizens so they do not become dependent on aid.
In Indonesia we have the same assets. Even stronger. The central government creates the roadmap and budget. Regional governments, who understand their regions’ character, are the executors. Village governments, with the Village Fund of Rp71 trillion in 2025, are the front line. NGOs and community figures act as supervisors and mentors. Universities and data-driven researchers craft policies to avoid trial and error. Without this collaboration, however large a programme, it will go nowhere. With this collaboration, 0% poverty is not a dream.
THE INDONESIAN PATH: HOW DO WE ADAPT?
One: build an Indonesian version of the ‘One Click System’. Unify Regsosek, DTKS, social affairs complaints, and the 171 call centre. Report via mobile phone. Verification within seven days. Assistance disbursed. This is the state responding quickly, in line with the fifth principle.
Two: policies matched to the character of the 3T regions (frontier, outermost, underdeveloped) plus pilot projects. Stop the uniform approach. Highland Papua: like Gansu. Focus on infrastructure, health, relocation from disaster-prone areas. East Nusa Tenggara: like Ningxia. Focus on water, dry land, solar power, the halal industry. Test. Evaluate. If successful, replicate across ten thousand villages.
Three: mobilise the ecosystem. Involve PKK, youth groups, village-owned enterprises (BUMDes), Islamic boarding schools, NGOs, and universities. Form ‘Poverty Acceleration Teams’ in every county. Composed of officials, academics, community figures, and civil society organisations. Coordinated, data-based evaluation.
Four: a binding roadmap. This is our homework. Create a poverty roadmap for 2025-2045. Make it a national political contract. Clear targets and budgets. It must not be changed every time a minister changes. Build an oversight system: BPK, KPK, Ombudsman, and society. Track funds down to the village. Enforce the law for every misuse. Poverty will not be resolved if funds leak along the way.
More than 10 years of travelling in and out of China has taught me: development is not instant, but it can be fast if there is direction, data, commitment, and continuity. China started from the poverty of the 1970s. We start from Pancasila. Combine China’s speed and precision. Because a nation’s progress is not measured by its tallest buildings, but by whether children in remote areas can attend school, mothers can access medical care, and no one falls into poverty again. Hopefully.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/lessons-from-ningxia-how-chinas-targeted-poverty-alleviation-can-inform-indonesias-2026-zero-extreme-poverty-1783637439)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/opini/909424/pelajaran-dari-ningxia), translated from Indonesian